Is it time to give the Dude a run?

[fowlen]

What you think?

Reina did not have much to do today but he still didn't look convincing.
Would it be worth giving Jerzy a run?

Personally when a player has a good few under par games they get dropped....and they normally bounce back. Should Reina be exempt from this?

[Shaggy]

No.

Reina's form is seriously worrying but he's a better keeper than Dudek. No point in bringing Jerzy in at all.

[lfc4ever]

It might be good for him to be benched for a couple of games so he can see the games and the defending from the managers POV, and be itching to get back to where he belongs.

[paulcooper4]

Reina is having a **** of a time. He should have done better with both bolton goals today. However, I wont let a reaction save and a penalty shootout cloud my judgement over dudek. Nice fella but I promise you reina is the better keeper.

[anfieldanfield]

No.

Reina's form is seriously worrying but he's a better keeper than Dudek. No point in bringing Jerzy in at all.

If we still had Carson at the club, I'd be tempted to give him five games to prove himself.

Dudek's not as bad as some make out, and Reina's in the worst form of his live.

[red g]

what a load of twaddle!!! Reina is by far the best choice in nets

[blacky]

Dudek would be an even bigger gamble however Reina's form is strating to worry me.................shame we let Carson go out on Loan

[Guest]

He's going through a dodgy period. This period will pass on and he'll be back to his best.

[G]

2 things can happen when your keeper is low on confidence and still gets picked.He can make a few good saves and get back to his best or he can keep making more and more stupid mistakes and let in more and more bad goals and never recover from it,which is what happened to Dudek.Reina worries me but so does Dudek.It is indeed a shame Carson's gone but he's getting much needed match time which,long run will be good for us if Pepe suffers irreversible damage.

[FowlerLeftFoot]

dude has a point to prove, use him

[Guest]

How old is the dude now ? 35 ?

[FowlerLeftFoot]

33 or 34 i guess

[Bob]

If we still had Carson at the club, I'd be tempted to give him five games to prove himself.

Carson apparently had another cracking game today. Next season he'll really push Reina!!!