Golden foot 2009

[Shaggy]

Most of the time Beckenbauer was a defender but he played a defensive role in midfield in the '66 World Cup final in order to nullify Bobby Charlton (and he may have done the same in the '70 QF - I don't remember). The tactic of playing a sweeper in front of the defence is certainly not a recent invention. I seem to recall an analysis of Dunga's role in '94 where it was suggested he held when Brazil attacked, providing a shield or cover for the centre backs while the two full backs went forward. If the opposition broke centrally then he went to close down the attack - if the opposition broke on one flank then he would drop into defence and allow a centre back to go wide.

I think a bit of a myth has built up about Makalele because he emerged during the Sky era and they base their whole approach to covering sport on individuals.

Although it's 'Makelele'

I agree although I do sometimes wonder if this whole Makelele myth is a complete fib. I remember the likes of Peter Reid, David Batty and stacks of others who rarely ventured forward. Back then they were usually described as 'ball-winners' or 'enforcers', and they were - I just struggle to recall them doing anything other than winning the ball and making a simple pass. These days you seldom hear of 'ball-winners' - just 'holding' or 'sitting' midfielders.

Or of course someone "in the Makelele role"

[MrsB]

Although it's 'Makelele'

One of the most misspelled names in football I reckon. I wonder why.

[Joe King]

One of the most misspelled names in football I reckon. I wonder why.

Along with Babbel and Veronin

[Mike]

Also hasselbaink and van bronchourst (if they are right)

[Shaggy]

One of them isn't

[Neil Young]

Although it's 'Makelele'

Oh **** off.

I agree although I do sometimes wonder if this whole Makelele myth is a complete fib. I remember the likes of Peter Reid, David Batty and stacks of others who rarely ventured forward. Back then they were usually described as 'ball-winners' or 'enforcers', and they were - I just struggle to recall them doing anything other than winning the ball and making a simple pass. These days you seldom hear of 'ball-winners' - just 'holding' or 'sitting' midfielders.

Or of course someone "in the Makelele role"

Sky are so crap - they pollute perceptions of the past.

[wiw]

Maldini surely