Should AA be made to keep his promise?

[Red_hot]

Despite his negativity which can be a bit depressing and the fact that we got off to a bad start I don't mind him. I think he is a decent poster. :shockhorror:

Yes really. I voted for option number 3.

[REDSCOUSER]

Marky19 YOU ARE THE WEAKEST LINK..bye bye

[kurtangle01]

AA should stay but Marky should go.



































Only joking I couldn't care less either way.

[Gaz]

The future of Marky's signature isn't looking too good

[Darth Marty]

ha ha ha i reckon a happy medium should be thought of, heres my solution....."sin bin" him instead of banning, say 3 days, ban the i.p address instead of the user details then hes ****ed :-D....for 3 days!! after all it was his idea..........
;-D

[Craig_H]

Nah, it's only a bit of a laugh, surely?

Of course, we may yet finish 4th, but that's not the point. It was a ludicrously negative thing to say either way. If we do finish 3rd it might make him think twice before making negative statements with such absolute certainty in the future

Doesnt he also have the Bellamy v Cisse one hanging round his neck too?

To be fair, i think he'll probably win that one.

Course he shouldnt be made to keep his promise, it's just a giggle as you say.

And no, marky shouldnt be banned either.

[Craig_H]

Honesty on the net, especially in forums can be a real mistake. I mean how do people know if Jules' homoerotic persona is real or just an interweb disguise? Maybe in real life AA is an eternal optimist?

Hehehe...

In real life AA is different - not an 'eternal optimist', but he winds you lot up a treat with his negativity and yet, people KEEP biting.

You'd be surprised about him in real life

[kendoddsdadsdogsdead]

Hehehe...

In real life AA is different - not an 'eternal optimist', but he winds you lot up a treat with his negativity and yet, people KEEP biting.

You'd be surprised about him in real life

Is he the one on the left or the right?

[Marky]

His negativity gets me down, it really does but i've warmed to him in the last while.
Although we argue alot but i think the mutual respect is there between the two of us, we're a similar age and are both diehard reds.

[Craig_H]

Is he the one on the left or the right?

[Red_Polo]

Doesnt he also have the Bellamy v Cisse one hanging round his neck too?

To be fair, i think he'll probably win that one.

Course he shouldnt be made to keep his promise, it's just a giggle as you say.

And no, marky shouldnt be banned either.

Yes he does have that particular remark to live up to as well! Win it you say?! Never!

Both of them could go either way really. He may well avoid a bit of embarrasment, although it has taken some decidedly patchy form from both Bellamy and the whole team for him to be in with a shout of being right about things which he declared would come true with great certainty.

Agree about Marky, he isn't everyone's cup of tea but he's pretty harmless on the whole.

[DannyMan2006]

Definitely let him stay. How **** would these forums be if everyone agreed with one another and kissed each others arses?

AA should stay.

If we all agreed this site would lose its charm, like Kraptalk when Dunk banned everyone who disagreed with him. The controversial ones are what makes the site great. AA, Marky19 and all the others should stay, though I doubt either will be asked to leave, this site isn't run by a bunch of muppets.

[Neil Young]

I like AnfieldDanfield and even if I didn't he should still stay of course.

Nah, it's only a bit of a laugh, surely?

Of course, we may yet finish 4th, but that's not the point. It was a ludicrously negative thing to say either way. If we do finish 3rd it might make him think twice before making negative statements with such absolute certainty in the future

Hehehe...

In real life AA is different - not an 'eternal optimist', but he winds you lot up a treat with his negativity and yet, people KEEP biting.

You'd be surprised about him in real life

His negativity doesn't annoy me but his sometime certainty bores me. Then again he's not the only one who sometimes has too much faith in his own opinion.

EDIT: That's directed at no-one in particular.

[Shaggy]

AA must stay!

[desertscouser]

If we all agreed this site would lose its charm, like Kraptalk when Dunk banned everyone who disagreed with him. The controversial ones are what makes the site great. AA, Marky19 and all the others should stay, though I doubt either will be asked to leave, this site isn't run by a bunch of muppets.

Agreed mate.

In AA's defence I actually agree with some of what he says. Sometimes his negative views are far more realistic than some of the blind optimisism that's spouted on here.