Martin Atkinson, Liverpool

[Craig_H]

It wasn't a pen, it was outside the box. But it was a definite handball, complete idiocy by Ngog.

It was on the line - so that's counted as in the box. Definite pen for me.

But the one on Kuyt, was ****ing obvious - and he just gave nothing.

[danperkins]

Athkinson got the peno spot on school boy stuff from Ngog, but he had a horrific game IMO and made so many wrong decisions. Shouldn't matter though we should have had the game wrapped.

[Exiled_red]

He was right to give the penalty, I don't know what Ngog was thinking, I don't think we can have any complaints about that. The freekick that resulted in the penalty however wasn't a freekick.

Also the bookings he gave two of which were for challenges where our players won the ball Nothing went our way, we should have had a penalty for the foul on Kuyt and there were a few occasions where Spurs players should have been booked but weren't. Classic 'homer' performance IMO

[DannyMan2006]

It was on the line - so that's counted as in the box. Definite pen for me.

But the one on Kuyt, was ****ing obvious - and he just gave nothing.

The wall was on the line, his arms were infront of him, like a boxer with his gloves up, and they were outside the area. But it was close so the fact the ref gave the pen isn't to much of a suprise.