Settling a debate....

[Chiccada]

Mate of mine (WHU fan, not a good start) seems to think this is the team that the scum will need if they want to win the CL next season. Disregard all the technicalities around signings etc etc and with only making 2 additions to any other team can you top the following:

Van der Saar

Neville Vidic Ferdinand Heinze

Ronaldo Scholes Mascherano Giggs

Rooney

Berbatov


I came up with this in response:

Buffon

Zambrotta Puyol Marquez Beletti

Iniesta Xavi Deco Ronaldiho

Eto'o Villa

Would you say my selection would beat the scum selection, or can you do better???

[Maestro]

Reina
Finnan Agger Carragher Arbeloa
Gerrard Mascherano Alonso Ribery
Eto'o Crouch

[tsb]

More than two changes but what the hey:

Carragher

Carragher Carragher Carragher Carragher

Carragher Carragher Carragher Carragher

Carragher Carragher

[simey85]

reina
finnan carragher agger arebola

gerrard xabi mascherano

kaka

kuyt eto'o

[Milan_Milan]

---------------Cech
Zambrotta---Carvalho---Terry---Cole
Ronaldo---Ballack---Essien---Robben
-----------Villa---Drogba

Is 3 changes, but if Sheva came back to form you could get rid of Villa.

[dww]

Mate of mine (WHU fan, not a good start) seems to think this is the team that the scum will need if they want to win the CL next season. Disregard all the technicalities around signings etc etc and with only making 2 additions to any other team can you top the following:

Van der Saar

Neville Vidic Ferdinand Heinze

Ronaldo Scholes Mascherano Giggs

Rooney

Berbatov


I came up with this in response:

Buffon

Zambrotta Puyol Marquez Beletti

Iniesta Xavi Deco Ronaldiho

Eto'o Villa

Would you say my selection would beat the scum selection, or can you do better???

I think that the central defensive partnership and midfield are not robust enough in your team. I think a well set up team would do a job on it in a similar way we did to Barca in the CL. Adding Villa would not be enough to convince me.

Swap Iniesta for Alonso, Makelele, or some other more defensive CM and I would give your team the edge.

[Parm]

---------------Cech
Zambrotta---Carvalho---Terry---Cole
Ronaldo---Ballack---Essien---Robben
-----------Villa---Drogba

Is 3 changes, but if Sheva came back to form you could get rid of Villa.

**** that looks a strong team.