Andy Carroll

[McDermotX]

Laughing stock, if that happens.

[Imy]

I predicted when we signed him he'd be back there sooner rather than later

[Chazza]

If Newcastle are seriously in for him then I can see it happening

[Vermilion]

Seems crazy to me, a young player we've over paid for fair enough, but one with potential and age on his side, if we're looking at taking the hit many say on the sale then it's madness, especially if we go out and pay nearly 10mill for a near 30yr old Dempsey with little or no sell on value.

[el matador]

We will not have a single ounce of credibility left in the transfer market and people will be rubbing their hands together in anticipation of liverpool arriving at the negotiation table.

Carroll should stay and fight for his place.

[baitman]

we should never loan carroll back to newcastle unless its a make weight in a deal that sees us buying ben arfa, cisse, krul or maybe ba.

[Chazza]

We will not have a single ounce of credibility left in the transfer market and people will be rubbing their hands together in anticipation of liverpool arriving at the negotiation table.

Carroll should stay and fight for his place.

I think he would like to stay and fight but if the manager doesn't want him then what choice does he have?

[Daniel 7]

Carroll to Newcastle.

Lets get Torres back and forget the last 18 months ever happened.



Whaddya say Chris?

[cream]

If we set a decent buy price then can't see a problem with it.

[Liverpool]

If we set a decent buy price then can't see a problem with it.

theyll just say no thanks after 12 months

[Bender]

Seems crazy to me, a young player we've over paid for fair enough, but one with potential and age on his side, if we're looking at taking the hit many say on the sale then it's madness, especially if we go out and pay nearly 10mill for a near 30yr old Dempsey with little or no sell on value.

carroll has no sell on value,unless he scores 30 goals a season every season but the fact we paid £35million make it nigh on impossible to make anything other than a huge loss on this deal...best option for lfc is swap him for other players usefull to BR

[el matador]

Theyre not going to.buy him back ffs.

Theyre going to use him for a season and tell us to do one. whatever.price we negotiate with.them before the loan you can divide that by two and thats closer to what they will pay.

No more loans. Havent we learned anything.

[cream]

theyll just say no thanks after 12 months

Better than him sitting on the bench and us paying his wages. Think of it as a shop window.

[Tee]

Yep, **** off with the loans. I would rather keep him and use him as a sub, Plan B when it is needed. £20m or **** right off, and I would apply that to anyone.

[cream]

FWIW, Dempsey is much, much better than Carroll.