Andy Carroll

[baitman]

No more loans. Havent we learned anything.

the only time we should consider loaning out a player is the help in the development of a youngster, to give them some extra real life football and build some strength, stamina and experience.

[Lee]

Carroll to Newcastle.

Lets get Torres back and forget the last 18 months ever happened.



Whaddya say Chris?

He'd explode.

You can see this though can't you, if Newcastle offer to take Carroll on loan.

"Never wanted to leave"
"Unfinished business"

Think this week is going to be an interesting one.

[Vermilion]

Yep, **** off with the loans. I would rather keep him and use him as a sub, Plan B when it is needed. £20m or **** right off, and I would apply that to anyone.

[Kenneth]

I don't care what we do with him really. We don't know how things will pan out and won't know whether we made the right decision for at least a year. :meh:

[Vermilion]

Where ever he go's he will score goals. imo.

[Bender]

PSG activate Demba Ba's buyout clause Hence the carroll bid:twitter

[cream]

Bye Andy.

[Vermilion]

TBH, Newcastle asking to loan AC must be one of the biggest piss takes in football..ever.

It's not like there's anything they need to find out about him ffs, cheeky ****s.

20mill or keep him. 17.5mill minimum. Half way is as low as we should go, and BR could do something with that.

[RedSince1964]

Yep, **** off with the loans. I would rather keep him and use him as a sub, Plan B when it is needed. £20m or **** right off, and I would apply that to anyone.

Agreed

[TheElephantMan]

I don't mind as long as he's being replaced with someone decent. I hope it's not Borini in and Carroll out - we need another striker.

[RichC]

Just as he started to look like he was going to be a handy player for us. Obviously its a rumour at the moment and I really hope it's not the case, as not only will we look ****ing ridiculous loaning hIm to Newcastle but we also will need to add in some extra fire power of which no doubt we'll get rinsed for as well.

Surely he deserves a chance to show what he can do especially if the alternative is a loan deal

[RedSince1964]

I don't mind as long as he's being replaced with someone decent. I hope it's not Borini in and Carroll out - we need another striker.

Yep

[el matador]

I reckon they would go to 20m for him. We need to dig in and take 20m plus add ons.

[Vermilion]

I like some physicality in the side too, while midgits may be the way forward , i like to see a big lump crash one in now and then a la AC England.

Sure BR knows what he's about though, just gotta trust him on this.

[marcus50bucks]

Newcastle will just do what Ac Milan did with Aquilani which is not take up the offer to buy him at the end of his loan deal. We'll get ****ed over again you just know it. I'd tell Newcastle to stick their loan offer up their arse. It's either a permanent move or Carroll stays.