12m for Crouch?

[Myo]

man, i would sell him for 10

[SouthAfricaRed]

you wouldnt take 12 mill for him?

Nope. He's unique. Who would you replace him with?

Liverpool must never be a selling club. With the investment almost here. Doesnt make sense to sell our players

[AFII]

Nope. He's unique. Who would you replace him with?

Liverpool must never be a selling club. With the investment almost here. Doesnt make sense to sell our players

Replace him with Klose. He is better at all the things Crouch is good at on the pitch and is probably the best striker in the box in the World.

[Morph]

I wouldn't unless we had a replacement already in the bag,and there's still a chance that said replacement wouldn't work out. I'd sooner let Robbie off the books first, and wait until we had a replacement already on the books, that way we could probably get more for him.

[tomasjj]

Nope. He's unique. Who would you replace him with?

Liverpool must never be a selling club. With the investment almost here. Doesnt make sense to sell our players

Yeah, he is unique, but he only a squad player imo, when we need something else. Replace him? A better striker, someone in the mould of Klose, Luca Toni,
There are many decifiencies in his game, too many for a club of our stature, especially if such a fantastic deal as 10-12 mill came along..

[SouthAfricaRed]

Replace him with Klose. He is better at all the things Crouch is good at on the pitch and is probably the best striker in the box in the World.

How much would Klose cost?

Klose would be cup tied for CL ? What happens when Bellamy picks up injury?

He's 28, Crouch is 25

Last Striker we signed from Germany was a countryman of mine - Sean Dundee

Crouch is our top scorer this season. He must have done something right.

I really dont understand the people on here. They are talking about replacing Momo (proven) with Mascherano (Failed at West Ham) and Crouch (proven EPL) with somebody that might do ok here.

Bottom line is this - We dont need the money

[AFII]

Klose would cost around £6m-£8m.

[SouthAfricaRed]

Yeah, he is unique, but he only a squad player imo, when we need something else. Replace him? A better striker, someone in the mould of Klose, Luca Toni,
There are many decifiencies in his game, too many for a club of our stature, especially if such a fantastic deal as 10-12 mill came along..

That's your opinion.

He's our Top scorer this season

10 goals from 17 starts. That's not bad

Kuijt has 7 goals from 21 starts
Bellamy has 6 goals from 19 starts

[SouthAfricaRed]

Klose would cost around £6m-£8m.

You failed to answer my question about CL

[AFII]

So you wouldn't sell Crouch for £12m and sign Klose for £6m-£8m?

Klose is probably the best 20-20 player together with Henry and Ronaldinho. Crouch is a good player but Klose is better IMO.

We have not been linked with Klose as far as I know the last six months.

[desertscouser]

I would be amazed if someone bid 12 million quid for Crouch but if they did it would be too good a deal to turn down.

[tomasjj]

That's your opinion.

He's our Top scorer this season

10 goals from 17 starts. That's not bad

Kuijt has 7 goals from 21 starts
Bellamy has 6 goals from 19 starts

Yep, just my opinion.
3 main points for me regarding Crouch and if a bid came for him:

1. He is a special option imo,which is very handy, but not a starter. 12 for one bench player is too good to turn down, especially considering no 2 and 3.
2. He is too wasteful. Should have had double the goals he has.
3. Too many weaknesses in his game.

Nothing against the lad, like.

I also think Momo is great, but he is not the new Vieira.
He lacks first touch and mainly, passing skills.
But I want us to keep Momo, we need his kind.

[AFII]

You failed to answer my question about CL

If we don't sign Neill then Rafa could pick Klose for the CL. A team is allowed to use one player that have played for another team in Europe this season. I think that rule is for both the UEFA and CL.

[SouthAfricaRed]

So you wouldn't sell Crouch for £12m and sign Klose for £6m-£8m?

Klose is probably the best 20-20 player together with Henry and Ronaldinho. Crouch is a good player but Klose is better IMO.

We have not been linked with Klose as far as I know the last six months.

Nope, because this is not Football manager.

I would not sell a proven player for a potentially good one. Klose might do OK in EPL. That's a Big IF he's available and wants to come to EPL.

Have you ever thought why Juve would pay 12 million for Crouch? Why dont they go for Klose or Luca Toni?

We need to replace Fowler, before we can think of selling one of the other 3 strikers

[SouthAfricaRed]

If we don't sign Neill then Rafa could pick Klose for the CL. A team is allowed to use one player that have played for another team in Europe this season. I think that rule is for both the UEFA and CL.

No it's not. It's only for UEFA cup. A player in CL is cup Tied. If not Morientes would have played in 2005