Steve Sidwell

[Robster007]

I'm sure he's been mentioned before as a possible purchase, and as young English talent goes, surely he has to be a consideration?

I'm watching the Reading vs Villa match and he is having yet another awesome game. He has terrorised the Villa players.

He currently has most of the attributes to be a top, top player. What do you lot think?

[kurtangle01]

Yeah I like him. He'd be a good addition to the squad but I'm 100% sure he would be a world beater for us. He's available on a free in the summer so he'd be worth a punt.

[keniget]

Yup, good player.

[thesilverfoxlfc]

I wouild like a better player then that coming in the door

[Robster007]

I wouild like a better player then that coming in the door

Define better, and i'm not asking for a cut and paste fron Collins Online Dictionary or such like.

[kurtangle01]

Define better, and i'm not asking for a cut and paste fron Collins Online Dictionary or such like.

Javier Mascherano?

[Robster007]

Javier Mascherano?

Time will tell I suppose. I just feel that Sidwell has a lot of potential.

[Meursault]

I just saw the match. Yes he scored a couple of goals against a very poor Villa side, but a lot of Reading moves also broke down due to him. Also couldn't make up his mind in crucial moments. He's a very very very poor man's Stevie G. We need alot more quality than Steven Sidwell.

Plus he is very ginger. How many ginger footballers did well for us in our history?

[thesilverfoxlfc]

Define better, and i'm not asking for a cut and paste fron Collins Online Dictionary or such like.

Kaka,Xavi for me

[Kopite_Colin]

Good player, but e need to address other areas of the team rather than CM right now.

[Shaggy]

Yeah he's a good player but no way should we be even thinking about signing him.

[Speedy]

Pedro Mendes scored today as well. Rob Hulse anyone?

[lfc4ever]

He is just not good enough, it's like the constant "we have to sign Barton" threads (who was back to his gash thuggish tackling self today btw).

They are where they are for a reason.

[Kopite_Colin]

I actually think we should have signed both Hulse and Ashton about 4-5 years ago when we had the chance.

[Shaggy]

I actually think we should have signed both Hulse and Ashton about 4-5 years ago when we had the chance.

Ashton I can understand, but Hulse?!?!?!?