Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Red Kit for the Final!
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Red Chilli View Post
Well it's true. He's not exactly played many games for us so far and I haven't been to any of the ones he has played. I don't think you can judge a player's performance on the TV, it's about as reliable as YouTube.
So should we get the mods to put a sticky at the top of the LFC Forum stating that only people who have actually gone to the game are permitted to comment on a player's performance?
Great idea.
Just when I discovered the meaning of life, they changed it
Comment
-
Originally posted by Maestro View Post
So should we get the mods to put a sticky at the top of the LFC Forum stating that only people who have actually gone to the game are permitted to comment on a player's performance?
Great idea.

No, I didn't say that either, you're just putting words into my post (so to speak).
I don't personally feel I can comment on a player having only watched them on the TV because having been to games it is quite clear that you get a distorted view from TV compared to watching the game in it's entirity.
If you can't handle the fact that I don't comment on performances I haven't seen live then that's tough **** I'm afraid.Originally posted by Gordon Brown
(1995)"A weak currency is the sign of a weak economy,which is the sign of a weak government"
Comment
-
I can handle mate, but I still find it funny.Originally posted by Red Chilli View PostNo, I didn't say that either, you're just putting words into my post (so to speak).
I don't personally feel I can comment on a player having only watched them on the TV because having been to games it is quite clear that you get a distorted view from TV compared to watching the game in it's entirity.
If you can't handle the fact that I don't comment on performances I haven't seen live then that's tough **** I'm afraid.
Just when I discovered the meaning of life, they changed it
Comment
-
I can indeed.Originally posted by Red Chilli View PostI'm sure you too can appreciate that TV creates artifacts and you see a different game if you are there live
But I also believe that anyone who has seen Mascherano on television thusfar in his Liverpool career is perfectly capable of forming an opinion on his performances. It's not like he's just played once.
I find it funny, because you were like a pit bull with something in his mouth when it came to dissing the Mascherano signing. You made a superhuman amount of posts regarding him (all negative), including having your sig devoted to him and now you refuse to comment on his performances.
I'm sure you can appreciate that?
Just when I discovered the meaning of life, they changed it
Comment
-
Originally posted by Maestro View PostI can indeed.
But I also believe that anyone who has seen Mascherano on television thusfar in his Liverpool career is perfectly capable of forming an opinion on his performances. It's not like he's just played once.
I find it funny, because you were like a pit bull with something in his mouth when it came to dissing the Mascherano signing. You made a superhuman amount of posts regarding him (all negative), including having your sig devoted to him and now you refuse to comment on his performances.
I'm sure you can appreciate that?
You have to admit I'm consistent, I never dissed his performances before he signed either.
I focussed more on the fact that he had a poor attitude and was a hypocritical mercenary, not the type of player I want at LFC.Originally posted by Gordon Brown
(1995)"A weak currency is the sign of a weak economy,which is the sign of a weak government"
Comment
-
You have to admit I'm consistent, I never dissed his performances before he signed either.
I focussed more on the fact that he had a poor attitude and was a hypocritical mercenary, not the type of player I want at LFC.
I hope every game he plays for us is a success, but it doesn't change my opinion of him and never will.
Had Lee Bowyer signed for us and played half a dozen great games, I wouldn't change my opinion of him either.Originally posted by Gordon Brown
(1995)"A weak currency is the sign of a weak economy,which is the sign of a weak government"
Comment
-
So you will comment on his attitude, although you have nothing to measure this by - yet you refuse to even comment on his performances for LFC despite having seen him play on TV?Originally posted by Red Chilli View PostYou have to admit I'm consistent, I never dissed his performances before he signed either.
I focussed more on the fact that he had a poor attitude and was a hypocritical mercenary, not the type of player I want at LFC.
You crack me up! Keep it coming!Just when I discovered the meaning of life, they changed it
Comment
-
I've quotes from the man himself which back up my opinion of his attitude.Originally posted by Maestro View PostSo you will comment on his attitude, although you have nothing to measure this by - yet you refuse to even comment on his performances for LFC despite having seen him play on TV?
You crack me up! Keep it coming!
The ones where in August 2006 he was delighted and honoured to be joining a great club like West Ham and then less than 6 months later he was slagging off the club and the management.
So before you laugh yourself silly saying I have nothing to measure it by, get your facts straight
Originally posted by Gordon Brown
(1995)"A weak currency is the sign of a weak economy,which is the sign of a weak government"
Comment
-
I'll just continue laughing mate.Originally posted by Red Chilli View PostI've quotes from the man himself which back up my opinion of his attitude.
The ones where in August 2006 he was delighted and honoured to be joining a great club like West Ham and then less than 6 months later he was slagging off the club and the management.
So before you laugh yourself silly saying I have nothing to measure it by, get your facts straight

Welcome back btw.
Just when I discovered the meaning of life, they changed it
Comment
Comment