LFC vs. Manure

[Mattshark]

nooo, think you misunderstood

im not saying theyd all be starters

the likes of hargreaves, nani and saha are good at least for the bench

Torres would be a starter just to make the strikers balanced and id take tevez over rooney

so the first eleven of mine would look like this

Torres - Tevez

Giggs - Gerrard - Scholes - Ronaldo

Evra - Vidic - Carragher - Finnan

Reina


also, disagree strongly on saha. very underrated player.

Saha is average
Never take Vidic over Agger or at the moment Evra over Arbeloa
Rather have Xabi and Mascher over Scholes.
Nani hasn't impressed me.

[Howard_lfc]

Scholes wimped out of England selection because he couldn't replace Gerrard or Lampturd.

Bollox of the highest order if I may say so.

Scholes was being shafted by SVEN - who was too scared to drop SG and/or Lampturd because he was afraid of the public outcry and the battering he'd get from the press. Instead - he moved Scholes to left midfield where he's about as much use as tits on a nun. Scholes (quite rightly) threw his hand in and quit the national team.

Just as an aside - has Cara 'wimped out' of England selection because he can't replace Terry or Ferdinand? Just asking like.

[flava]

Reina, Finnan, Carvalho, Carra, A.Cole, Pennant/SWP (tough to call as Pennant's been awesome so far this season), Gerrard, Mascherano/Essien (tough to call again), Joe Cole, Torres, Drogba

[Johnny]

he actually retired because he was being ****ed around by sven and getting stuck out on the left wing when in reality hes the best CM in england alongisde stevie

would you call carra a coward for quitting england for similar reasons as the ginger one?

Your nut`s pal.

[Howard_lfc]

Your nut`s pal.

He's not that far off the mark Quincy.

[El Jefecito]

Reina, Finnan, Carvalho, Carra, A.Cole, Pennant/SWP (tough to call as Pennant's been awesome so far this season), Gerrard, Mascherano/Essien (tough to call again), Joe Cole, Torres, Drogba

EXCEPT: Eljefecito for Essien. Agger for Carvalno; Malouda for Cole and Aurelio/Insua for cole in his current form. BTW I'd also have Crouch on the bench for Saha / Rooney(Tevez).

[Johnny]

in my opinon;

Cech

Finnan
Carvalho
Carra
Cole

SWP
Gerrard
Essien
Malouda

Drogba
Torres

Sniff,sniff.







I smell a WUM.

[yukpo]

Your nut`s pal.

Sniff,sniff.







I smell a WUM.

eh? think thats pretty much spot on and speedy seemed to disagree only about Carvalho. is he a WUM aswell?

[flava]

EXCEPT: Eljefecito for Essien. Agger for Carvalno; Malouda for Cole and Aurelio/Insua for cole in his current form. BTW I'd also have Crouch on the bench for Saha / Rooney(Tevez).

I really rate Cole and prefer him to Malouda, who i've barely seen. Insua over Ashley Cole is just ridiculous though - you'd have a case for Arbeloa on Current form. As I said, undecided on Essien n Masch because they're both beasts. Carvalho is criminally underrated on this forum - he's a very classy player.

[El Jefecito]

I really rate Cole and prefer him to Malouda, who i've barely seen. Insua over Ashley Cole is just ridiculous though - you'd have a case for Arbeloa on Current form. As I said, undecided on Essien n Masch because they're both beasts. Carvalho is criminally underrated on this forum - he's a very classy player.

Agree I should have said Arbeloa / Insua / Riise / Aurelio is a better combo than chelsea have.

[Johnny]

in my opinon;

Cech

Finnan
Carvalho
Carra
Cole

SWP
Gerrard
Essien
Malouda

Drogba
Torres

nooo, think you misunderstood

im not saying theyd all be starters

the likes of hargreaves, nani and saha are good at least for the bench

Torres would be a starter just to make the strikers balanced and id take tevez over rooney

so the first eleven of mine would look like this

Torres - Tevez

Giggs - Gerrard - Scholes - Ronaldo

Evra - Vidic - Carragher - Finnan

Reina


also, disagree strongly on saha. very underrated player.

Your inclusion of Cech,Carvalho,Swp,Essien,Vidic,Scholes and Tevez makes me think your on a wind up or you don`t much rate the best young CM in the league or 2 "World class" CM`s and your picking Tevez on the strength of 7 games last season.Your nut`s.

[rushscored4]

As Rafa might say though, "OK, the best 11 players do not always make the best team, no?"

[Red Chilli]

Bollox of the highest order if I may say so.

Scholes was being shafted by SVEN - who was too scared to drop SG and/or Lampturd because he was afraid of the public outcry and the battering he'd get from the press. Instead - he moved Scholes to left midfield where he's about as much use as tits on a nun. Scholes (quite rightly) threw his hand in and quit the national team.

Just as an aside - has Cara 'wimped out' of England selection because he can't replace Terry or Ferdinand? Just asking like.

The difference between Carra and Scholes in my opinion is that Carra wasn't even Sven's 3rd, 4th or 5th choice centre back whereas Scholes was his 3rd choice central midfielder. Carra put up with being played out of position and dropped behind ****e players for YEARS, Scholes lasted what, 6 months?

But all that doesn't really matter because the point is 2007 Paul Scholes wouldn't get anywhere near our first team because he's past it and mediocre at best

[Matty100]

Sorry i've missed Malouda's contribution this season,and as for the Rooney hype,what has he done for the mancs or england in last 12 months

[El Jefecito]

Sorry i've missed Malouda's contribution this season,and as for the Rooney hype,what has he done for the mancs or england in last 12 months