A tasking for by son 14 years old....

[SB]

[QUOTE=kev776;1144578]

no fella the original post i meant

tbh i thought it was a **** post
still its easy to hide behind a 14 year old eh


[/QUOTE


why be so nasty. Im 48 years of age I dont have to hide behind my son.

It is not a pop at Rafa by me, but what a young lad thought about over the weekend

1960 was indeed a good year Kev

12th May a particularly good day I could add

[shankly]

My son was ill over the weekend and bored so I told him to analyse our first team squad and comment. He is 14 and German so does not follow the UK press

Keane is to old not worth 20m

Torres is good but gives the ball away to much, has to many "heads down and charge" periods, which is the opposite of what he (my son) gets taught in training.

Aurelio, Arbeloa, Pennant, Benny, Veronnin, Finnen, Kuyt, Deggen and Hyypa are not good enough to win the title.

More reserves should be given a chance.

Barry is the wrong man and not worth 18m

we need 2 class wingers to feed the strikers

Babel is a striker not a winger.

Rafas tactics suck

I gave him an A- for his efforts.

And I bet he says the ball wasn't over the line in '66 doesn't he !

[NicoBernetini]

How many times have you seen Degen play in the prermiership?
Nice to see hes or you are basing your opinions on what you have seen.

And if you got rid of all those players we would have 11 players more a less, great squad there.
Apart from Chelsea name a team with world class players in every position?
Wouldnt say Brown is world class, nor Oshea, nor fletcher, nor any of their other ****e behind their strikers and ronaldo

[Resu]

How many times have you seen Degen play in the prermiership?Nice to see hes or you are basing your opinions on what you have seen.

And if you got rid of all those players we would have 11 players more a less, great squad there.
Apart from Chelsea name a team with world class players in every position?
Wouldnt say Brown is world class, nor Oshea, nor fletcher, nor any of their other ****e behind their strikers and ronaldo

As his son is Germany there is a fair chance he`s seen Degen a few times, and should have a good idea if he`s good enough for the PL. Degen would not at the club if he wasn`t for free, but hopefully he`ll come good.

As for players not good enough to win the title I agree on most of them.

And Brown, O`shea and Fletcher may not be world class, but they are good enough to win league, and win it several times as well.

There are some people on here going crazy with their anti-Rafa agenda, but that doesn`t mean that all critism of him are wrong.


All in all I thought it pretty insighfull from a 14 year old, and shows more maturity and understanding than some grown-up here (This wasn`t aimed at you Nico, but a general observation).

[NicoBernetini]

As his son is Germany there is a fair chance he`s seen Degen a few times, and should have a good idea if he`s good enough for the PL. Degen would not at the club if he wasn`t for free, but hopefully he`ll come good.

As for players not good enough to win the title I agree on most of them.

And Brown, O`shea and Fletcher may not be world class, but they are good enough to win league, and win it several times as well.

There are some people on here going crazy with their anti-Rafa agenda, but that doesn`t mean that all critism of him are wrong.


All in all I thought it pretty insighfull from a 14 year old, and shows more maturity and understanding than some grown-up here (This wasn`t aimed at you Nico, but a general observation).

People in Holland thought Kuyt was going to be incredible in the premiership.
It doesnt work like that at all, its a completely different league.

Also with the others, their squad players, are you saying those 3 are really better than Arbeloa, Benayoun and Kuyt? I dont think so really.

[kev776]

[QUOTE=SB;1144647]

1960 was indeed a good year Kev

12th May a particularly good day I could add

Like a fine wine sir, 26 May for me, I am just a pup.

[Resu]

People in Holland thought Kuyt was going to be incredible in the premiership.
It doesnt work like that at all, its a completely different league.

Also with the others, their squad players, are you saying those 3 are really better than Arbeloa, Benayoun and Kuyt? I dont think so really.

Kuyt was one of the stars in Holland, but Degen was just an average Bundesliga player. Bundesliga is a better league than Eresdivision, but I still think you have to excel in Bundesliga to become a good PL player.
As for Arbeloa and Kuyt, they are startes for us but I don`t think they would start much for the other top four sides. I actually like both of them, but they have their limitations as players. Benayoun is a squad player for (and a handy one) but nothing more IMO.

Maybe I`m a bit harsh on these three players (Plus Hyypia, and Aurelio (Good player, but "never match fit")), but the rest of the kids list I agree with

[kev776]

And I bet he says the ball wasn't over the line in '66 doesn't he !

Actually he only has Liverpool and England shirts, him and his older brother are the only LFC shirts at football training amongst a sea of Dortmund, Bayern and Schalke ****e.