Worst decision ever made? Aldo

[Red Wino]

Bad decision indeed. Aldo should've decided to put the ball in the other corner at that penalty kick.

[Woobus]

Be interested to see the article about his subs tho, cos I dont have that impression sadly.

I think it was posted on here a while back maybe someone else has it to hand or knows were it is. I didnt have that impression myself before I read it, but that is mostly down to only remembering his subs when we drop points. When we have won due to his subs it really is never brought up by anyone and I am normally to happy to care.
Its like rotation it only ever crops up when we drop points even though we do it all the time.

[mooha]

Worst desicion ever made? Are you having a laugh?
I think it's easier for me as an "foreign" LFC fan - as opposite to "local" - to see Steven Gerrard as "just another midfielder". I even sometimes come to the conclusion that he is overrated.
Albeit our most influential, inspirational and clinical player on his day, I think on some of his off-days he deserves a substitution just as anybody else. Who knows, he might even benefit as a player by few more of those subs when he's sulking and not performing on the field.

[pondus]

I think the article is pretty much spot on.

Well said

Think it echoes how 95% or more of us feel...

Yep definately up there with one of the worst decisions i have ever witnessed.

So what he was tired, you think he was full of energy in the FA Cup final?

One swing of that right boot can win us the game. We had no attacking threat when he went off.

Shocking decision

Well said.

Brilliantly put, great piece.

great piece - replacing a player cos he is "tired" 7 odd minutes from time is crazy
i bet stevie never asked to be taken off

Its just such a shame that he is too stuborn to change these stupid decisions he makes. It will end up costing him his job. If only he would not make these silly changes i seriously think we would be points clear at the top and on for the title!

Why bother resting him for Chelsea when we cannot even beat Wigan?

Save him at 2 - 0 up by all means. Not when we're drawing.

[Winstonio]

Worst desicion ever made? Are you having a laugh?
I think it's easier for me as an "foreign" LFC fan - as opposite to "local" - to see Steven Gerrard as "just another midfielder". I even sometimes come to the conclusion that he is overrated.
Albeit our most influential, inspirational and clinical player on his day, I think on some of his off-days he deserves a substitution just as anybody else. Who knows, he might even benefit as a player by few more of those subs when he's sulking and not performing on the field.

Are you mad? Absolutely crazy?

Add up the amount of points Gerrard has won us this season itself, you could be in for a shock. We wouldn't even be anywere near the top 4 if it wasn't for him this season. Especially with no Torres.

7 minutes to go, needing a goal with no Torres? You ask any fan in the league who they would want on the pitch if they needed a goal in that situation, I GUARENTEE you Gerrard would be in the top 3.

He doesn't have a habit or anything of scoring vital goals or goals in the last few minutes of games does he

[Helios Creed]

What energy will have been saved in that 7 minutes though? **** all. ok you could argue it may have prevented a possible injury occurring, but Rafa certainly can't read the future anymore than he knows how to break down a stubborn defence.

Why bother resting him for Chelsea when we cannot even beat Wigan?

Save him at 2 - 0 up by all means. Not when we're drawing.

I didn't say I agreed with it, but I haven't seen or heard a single person mention that it could have been a factor, and I suspect that it was and that Rafa thinks we should still be able to beat Wigan using other players in the squad, also fear of unnecessary injury through tiredness and hadn't Brown been kicking lumps out of him?

[frank the tank]

at the end of the day.....

YES....aldo was an awesome LFC player....

YES.............aldo is a legend still - his passion for LFC is great - comparable to Thommo....

But......NO NO ****IN' NO....is aldo fit to tell rafa how to do his job........ how many jobs ya get after tranmere aldo????? meanwhile rafa is a LaLiga, UEFA Cup, Champions League winning manager......

i know you are paid to give you opinion..........and that your opinion sells papers or whatever.....but **** off aldo