Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Big Spend Debate

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    The Big Spend Debate

    Hopefully this will work, but I’m trying put a few figures together to quash the ridiculous rumour that Rafa has spent more than Ferguson. Gross spend isn’t an accurate barometer as Rafa has had to sell to buy and total net doesn’t give a fair reflection as Ferguson cashed in on academy / youth players like Richardson, Butt, Neville etc and sold players bought pre-Rafa.

    The only fair way to judge is to concentrate only on players bought during Rafa’s reign, likewise it should only be these players that contribute to the net spend.

    Figures as always are quite ambiguous and are taken from different sites, but if anything I’ve leant generously towards United.

    Feel free to nitpick or provide more accurate figures as I would generally like to see the results.
    If we are all only happy when we are really winning in the end, when your race finishes, what life would that be?

    #2
    Obviously the Excel file didn’t add, but here is the breakdown…

    Rafa...


    Riera 8m - 2008
    Keane 19m - 2008
    Keane -16m - 2008
    N'Gog 1.5m - 2008
    Cavalieri 3.5m - 2008
    Dossena 7m - 2008
    Degen 0 2008
    Skrtel 6.5m - 2008


    Insua 1.3m - 2007
    Mascherano 17m - 2007
    Arbeloa 2.6m - 2007
    Lucas 6m - 2007
    Voronin 0 2007
    Leto 1.85m - 2007
    Duran 0 2007
    Itange 0 2007
    Torres 20m - 2007
    Benni 5m - 2007
    Babel 11.5m - 2007


    Aurelio 0 2006
    Pennant 6.7m - 2006
    Kuyt 9m - 2006
    Palletta 2m - 2006
    Palletta -1.3m - 2006
    Bellamy 6m - 2006
    Bellamy -7.5m - 2006
    Agger 5.8m - 2006
    Fowler 0 2006
    Kronkamp 0 2006
    Kronkamp -2m - 2006
    El Zhar 0 2006


    Crouch 7m - 2005
    Crouch -9m - 2005
    Sissoko 5.6m - 2005
    Sissoko -8.2m - 2005
    Gonzalez 4.5m - 2005
    Gonzalez -4.2m - 2005
    Barragan 0.24m - 2005
    Barragan -0.675m - 2005
    Reina 6m - 2005
    Zenden 0 2005
    Carson 0.75m - 2005
    Carson -3.25m - 2005
    Morienties 6.3m - 2005
    Morienties -3m - 2005
    Pellegrino 0 2005
    Pellegrino 0 2005


    Josemi 2m - 2004
    Josemi 0 2004
    Garcia 6m - 2004
    Garcia -4m - 2004
    Zabi 10.5m - 2004
    Nunez 0 2004
    Nunez -1.5m - 2004


    Total: £128.515m
    Last edited by RedReet; 22-03-09, 01:58 PM.
    If we are all only happy when we are really winning in the end, when your race finishes, what life would that be?

    Comment


      #3
      Ferguson...


      Tosic 8m - 2009
      Ljasic 0 2009


      Berbatov 30m - 2008
      Fabio 0 2008
      Rafael 0 2008
      Possebon 0 2008


      Hargreaves 17 2007
      Anderson 15m - 2007
      Nani 14m - 2007
      Tevez 10m - 2007


      Carrick 18.6m - 2006
      Kuszczak 2.5m - 2006
      Evra 5.5m - 2006
      Vidic 7m - 2006


      Park 4m - 2005
      Foster 1m - 2005
      Van Der Sar 2.5m - 2005


      Rooney 27m - 2004
      N'Galula 0 2004
      Miller 0 2004
      Miller 0 2004
      Heinze 6.9m - 2004
      Heinze -8m - 2004
      Smith 7m - 2004
      Smith -6m - 2004


      Total: £162m
      Last edited by RedReet; 22-03-09, 01:59 PM.
      If we are all only happy when we are really winning in the end, when your race finishes, what life would that be?

      Comment


        #4
        Wasn't Berbatov £32m?
        Thanks very much for being ‘This Mornings’ Farmer’

        Comment


          #5
          As I said, I was very generous. Could get accurate prices for the kids at Christmas or the Brazilians from the summer.
          If we are all only happy when we are really winning in the end, when your race finishes, what life would that be?

          Comment


            #6
            Sack swinging like Dub-D40 on a door hinge

            Comment

            Working...
            X