Dilemma!!!!

[Joe King]

I have just won a signed Premier League shirt signed by a player of my own choosing from the Guardian after submitting my chalkboard - which I posted on here after the United game: Chalkboard

So I have choice between Gerrard and Torres. Help me decide, I can't lose either way.

[MrsB]

Gareth Barry.

[Joe King]

Thanks for bumping the thread.

[S-RED]

Dossena

[cadmium]

Villa

[MrsB]

1) The new and improved Steven Gerrard

This week's winner is elterrible, who believes Benítez's decision to deploy Steven Gerrard just behind Fernando Torres, rather than in his conventional central-midfield role, was the key to Liverpool's triumph at Old Trafford. Whereas Gerrard spent much of last year's corresponding fixture – which United won 3-0 – battling for possession deep in his own half, this year he was based far higher up the pitch. Among other benefits, this ensured Fernando Torres never became isolated.

"Steven Gerrard and Fernando Torres should be seen as a bona fide strike partnership now, such is their interplay and such is Gerrard's advanced role in the formaition," says Alexander. "Just like Dalglish and Rush or Beardsley and Aldridge, the pair have the ability to cause havoc in even the best defences."

Well done, elterrible!

[Joe King]

Well done, elterrible!

Thank you

It should be pronounced as el terriblé, but whatever.

[MrsB]

Well, you have to pronounce the last e of terrible, but the accent is on the i.

[Joe King]

Well, you have to pronounce the last e of terrible, but the accent is on the i.

Ah I see. I'm not too learned on the linguistics of various different languages.

[DannyMan2006]

Well comments about Gerrard won you the shirt so I'd get his. Plus Gerrard is an LFC legend already so it's guaranteed pride of place in your collection for years to come.

With Torres you never know what might happen. He could piss off tomorrow or get found out and you'd be stuck with a shirt that belonged to a player who had little impact on our history. It's not gonna happen mind, but whatever happens Gerrard is guaranteed to be a shirt worth having for years. Torres isn't.

[Shanks]

With Torres you never know what might happen. He could piss off tomorrow or get found out

Oh Ye Of Little Faith.

[EwarWoo]

Carra. Never mind the glamour boys, go the heart of the team.

[RedReet]

Well comments about Gerrard won you the shirt so I'd get his. Plus Gerrard is an LFC legend already so it's guaranteed pride of place in your collection for years to come.

With Torres you never know what might happen. He could piss off tomorrow or get found out and you'd be stuck with a shirt that belonged to a player who had little impact on our history. It's not gonna happen mind, but whatever happens Gerrard is guaranteed to be a shirt worth having for years. Torres isn't.

[Leyton388]

Degan or Keane

[Chris]

Whoever would get you the most on ebay.