2012: The Ideal Path to #19

[Kenneth]

Agree Cahill will be way overpriced so would leave that one. But, I can reapply see young under Kenny being a very handy player.

[Rudo]

Can't help but feel you're playing to the crowd when you come out with remarks like this.

[Mostar]

I really do not think Cahill or Young would be good. Cahill is not good enough to be anything other than 4th choice and for his price that would not be good and Young is a headless chicken. I would be severely unimpressed with the club if we do this.

Perhaps he's not a flashy signing but he'd be the first choice CB in every PL club including us.

[Mattshark]

Perhaps he's not a flashy signing but he'd be the first choice CB in every PL club including us.

He is also error prone, he is never good enough to be first choice for us. And to suggest he'd be ahead of Vidic or Ferdinand is ridiculous.

[Mostar]

I get that you don't rate him (he's not my first choice either) but it is silly to say that he would be our 4th choice.

In terms of ManU Ferdinand is not nearly a player he once was and I am not so sure that if Cahill were there he would be an automatic starter.

[Mattshark]

I get that you don't rate him (he's not my first choice either) but it is silly to say that he would be our 4th choice.

In terms of ManU Ferdinand is not nearly a player he once was and I am not so sure that if Cahill were there he would be an automatic starter.

It isn't though, he is not better than Carragher, Agger or Skrtel imo so he would be fourth choice.

Ferdinand is still a far better player than Cahill.

[Mostar]

It isn't though, he is not better than Carragher, Agger or Skrtel imo so he would be fourth choice.

Ferdinand is still a far better player than Cahill.

Agger when fit is definitely better player but other 2 are not.

At 32 Rio is not a player he once was just like Carra.

I think Kenny will be going after CB this summer and Cahill could easily be his top pick and he would certainly not doing that to improve our 4th choice option.

[Mattshark]

Agger when fit is definitely better player but other 2 are not.

At 32 Rio is not a player he once was just like Carra.

I think Kenny will be going after CB this summer and Cahill could easily be his top pick and he would certainly not doing that to improve our 4th choice option.

They really are, Cahill is distinctly average and hasn't even looked average in some games.
I genuinely would not want to see Cahill at at Liverpool.

He maybe 32 but he and Carra are both still better than a 25 year old Cahill.

[Kenneth]

Off the field, it's a tragic shame that we didn't get Sami back as a coach. He's coaching at Leverkusen now

[Mattshark]

Off the field, it's a tragic shame that we didn't get Dami back as a coach. He's coaching at Leverkusen now

[PTP]

Try Goetze and Borussia Dortmund.. Great talent and it would be a big thing to snatch him now before he becomes a mega star.

lol - i know, i was just doing a play on the word goatse

[Mostar]

They really are, Cahill is distinctly average and hasn't even looked average in some games.
I genuinely would not want to see Cahill at at Liverpool.

He maybe 32 but he and Carra are both still better than a 25 year old Cahill.

Cahill wouldn't be my first choice CB but I wouldn't be that opposed if he joins us.

Rio is 32 and he and Carra are more mature and experienced than Cahill but not better. Both are past their best but in case of Rio that seems to be less gradual.

Gary can give you offensive productivity (13 goals and 4 assists in last 3 years) which Rio failed to do any in last 2 seasons and Carra never had and that shouldn't be overlooked.

[Mostar]

lol - i know, i was just doing a play on the word goatse

[Mattshark]

Cahill wouldn't be my first choice CB but I wouldn't be that opposed if he joins us.

Rio is 32 and he and Carra are more mature and experienced than Cahill but not better. Both are past their best but in case of Rio that seems to be less gradual.

Cahill can give you offensive productivity (13 goals and 4 assists in last 3 years) which Rio failed to do any in ast 2 and Carra never had.

He can, but that is not what we would be signing him. Defensively he is no way near as sound as either Carra or Rio.

Sorry mate, I really think Cahill would be an awful signing, I have nothing in his play to suggest otherwise.

[Mostar]

He can, but that is not what we would be signing him. Defensively he is no way near as sound as either Carra or Rio.

Sorry mate, I really think Cahill would be an awful signing, I have nothing in his play to suggest otherwise.

I hear you. Yes he would not be a great signing but there aren't too many good CBs that will be available this summer for reasonable fee and if Kenny thinks he's the the one so be it.