Simon Mignolet

[Gazzla]

I thought Mignolet was at fault for at least 2 of the goals, admittedly the defending in front didn't help but the first shot went right through him, he almost tried to dive out of the way, the second goal Johnson blocked him on the goal line so he couldn't dive, it was a cluster**** but not really his doing but the third was atrocious, what he was attempting I don't know but he made it so easy and it wasn't good enough. Bad day all over the pitch but the goals they scored were preventable in several areas including goalkeeping

[Exiled_red]

He wasn't great last night but for me the biggest problem was the defence in front of him, too many mistakes left him exposed, his positioning was questionable for Aguero's goal, but I don't think he could have done anything about the others.

[Pablo]

Horrendous positioning for the third goal Comfortably beaten at the near post too for the first goal.

I gave him MOTM against Southampton but I admit he does still worry me. He reminds me a bit of Sander Westerweld. There's some quality there but he's just a bit shaky.

We should have gone for Begovic instead shouldn't we?

[Rich]

We should have gone for Begovic instead shouldn't we?

Looks like it.

[Tee]

Horrendous positioning for the third goal Comfortably beaten at the near post too for the first goal.

I gave him MOTM against Southampton but I admit he does still worry me. He reminds me a bit of Sander Westerweld. There's some quality there but he's just a bit shaky.

We should have gone for Begovic instead shouldn't we?

Not too late though is it?

[BobTheCharmer]

There aren't many keepers who would of saved the first goal it was hit so quickly. The much castigated third was pretty much irrelevant as the game was gone at 2-0. I'm all for keepers ****ing up when the game is gone rather than at 0-0. I think he's got much more vocal since the summer. I also think he's trying to catch more crosses. His kicking has also much improved, he kept calm and found our players the majority of the time, there were two occasions he chipped it to the wing and our man was beaten but then it is no different to when a keeper used to punt it downfield, it always becomes a 50/50. Some just want a scapegoat. He won us the 3 points last week with that great save. The defenders in front of him helped lose this game.

[Exiled_red]

Horrendous positioning for the third goal Comfortably beaten at the near post too for the first goal.

I gave him MOTM against Southampton but I admit he does still worry me. He reminds me a bit of Sander Westerweld. There's some quality there but he's just a bit shaky.

We should have gone for Begovic instead shouldn't we?

While I agree the positioning was poor for the third, I'm not sure there is much he can do about the first, it is put low by his feet (though his legs in fact) which IMO is just a good finish by the striker. The mistake for that one come from the defence.

[Pablo]

While I agree the positioning was poor for the third, I'm not sure there is much he can do about the first, it is put low by his feet (though his legs in fact) which IMO is just a good finish by the striker. The mistake for that one come from the defence.

Not majorly culpable for the first goal no, although no keeper likes to get beaten at his near post, and it was still saveable with his legs IMO.

Third goal killed the game though and his positioning was just amateurish

[Bender]

Problem with Mignolet is he isn't an imposing figure in goal/pen area as a keeper or physically,nor does he seem a keeper who is very verbal

[Chris]

We should have gone for Begovic instead shouldn't we?

Is this a grass is greener thing? As he's cost Stoke points in both their games so far.

[Pablo]

Is this a grass is greener thing? As he's cost Stoke points in both their games so far.

Yeah he wasn't great the other day, I watched a bit of it.

It might be, he seems to be in a dodgy patch himself, he probably just wants out to be honest.

I guess I'm just voicing my internal thoughts that we might have got the wrong man. I think Rodgers and the staff probably have the same concern to some degree.

[RedReet]

Horrendous positioning for the third goal Comfortably beaten at the near post too for the first goal.

I gave him MOTM against Southampton but I admit he does still worry me. He reminds me a bit of Sander Westerweld. There's some quality there but he's just a bit shaky.

We should have gone for Begovic instead shouldn't we?

He's had a terrible start to the season for Stoke.

[Chris]

Yeah he wasn't great the other day, I watched a bit of it.

It might be, he seems to be in a dodgy patch himself, he probably just wants out to be honest.

I guess I'm just voicing my internal thoughts that we might have got the wrong man. I think Rodgers and the staff probably have the same concern to some degree.

Theres defo concerns with his game. I'd love us to offer Valdes a cheap deal and see if he bites, though perhaps signing a 32 year old who's had a massive injury and is reliant on his speed and agility isn't the best idea!

[Leyton388]

Cech would be perfect and if we could get him we should but i don't think Chelsea will sell to us.

[danperkins]

Horrendous positioning for the third goal Comfortably beaten at the near post too for the first goal.

I gave him MOTM against Southampton but I admit he does still worry me. He reminds me a bit of Sander Westerweld. There's some quality there but he's just a bit shaky.

We should have gone for Begovic instead shouldn't we?

Begovic is an outstanding keeper that really has stayed at Stoke too long.