Simon Mignolet

[Leyton388]

I used to think Phil Babb was the worst but this guy takes the title.

[Red_Polo]

I used to think Phil Babb was the worst but this guy takes the title.

Don't think he's anywhere near the worst of all time, but as Chris said the number of appearances he has considering his level is an absolute shocker

[Chris]

Just had a look at the list of LFC players by number of appearances. The answer is yes, and to say comfortably is putting it mildly.

Yeah thought he'd be up there. 4 ****ing years by the end of the season he's been in goal for! While our rivals had and have the likes of De Gea, Courtois, Lloris etc. This needs to be addressed in the summer, it seems like Klopp doesn't rate him that much going by the Karius signing so hopefully it's still the case! He gives us nothing really, good at saving pens but we'll give away what 2 or 3 in a season! Useless with the ball, doesn't command his area (though he's improved a little bit at it tbf) and while goalie stats are dodgy he's constantly among the lowest for save percentage in the league which is backed up by eyes too, never really feels like he bails us out apart from the occasional game like Utd away. And he's got no personality whatsoever. In fairness he's not the only problem and it's probably not easy to play behind some of the **** he's had to but equally its not easy for them to play infront of him!

[Big-Red-Ed]

Same old Mig. Gets dropped for being wick. Replacement comes in and makes a ****tard of himself, gets dropped. Mig comes back in and plays ok for a while then gets dropped for being wick. Rinse and repeat.

Sent from my P01M using Tapatalk

[McDermotX]

Same old Mig. Gets dropped for being wick. Replacement comes in and makes a ****tard of himself, gets dropped. Mig comes back in and plays ok for a while then gets dropped for being wick. Rinse and repeat.

Sent from my P01M using Tapatalk

He's ****ing wick alright.

Gets right on my wick anyway.

[Big-Red-Ed]

I know its not very mature of me but I can't the sight of him in the team.

Sent from my P01M using Tapatalk

[Daniel 7]

He's still a better option than Karius

[Charly]

Got to be the worst player to ever play this many games for the club surely? Utterly horrific.

Mike Hooper v Anders Limpar

[Chazza]

He's **** and we need to stick with Karius from here on in to see if he is any good.

I'm sure Kenneth will dispute the above but well......meh

[Chris]

Agreed, give Karius another go, he had a rocky start but looked good in the cup v Southampton x 2. I know he's despised by many on here already but maybe he'll keep improving, maybe he'll be **** but finding out the answer to that is better than keeping a proven failure in the team. And please for the love of god no more Lucas at centre back while Joe Gomez sits on the bench. If we are gonna play mistake ridden players might as well make them young ones who might learn from them instead of **** or shot seniors.

[brightred]

Agreed, give Karius another go, he had a rocky start but looked good in the cup v Southampton x 2. I know he's despised by many on here already but maybe he'll keep improving, maybe he'll be **** but finding out the answer to that is better than keeping a proven failure in the team. And please for the love of god no more Lucas at centre back while Joe Gomez sits on the bench. If we are gonna play mistake ridden players might as well make them young ones who might learn from them instead of **** or shot seniors.

Looks like we're comparing ****e with ****e.

[Exiled_red]

I don't have a problem with giving Karius more time in the league to adapt him and Mignolet seem about the same level, but from what I've seen of both neither is good enough. Hopefully Karius will improve because of his age, but I don't see Mignolet getting any better.

[Daniel 7]

I'd sooner go for Joe Hart in the summer than either of who we have. He's not amazing, is annoying and has an objectionable face, but he's better than most of what is available on the market, and is better than what we have.

[Slinky Skills]

No he isn't he's ****ing rubbish mate I'm sorry. He's just as bad as Mignolet and Karius. FFS I don't understand why it's so hard for this football club to find a decent keeper. We always have absolutely terrible goalkeepers. ****ing sort it.

[Daffy Duck]

Found an old training clip of him from the summer we signed him.

[ame="http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x11jjgi_ibe_sport"]Ibe - Video Dailymotion[/ame]

We should have known