Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Some ratings

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Some ratings

    1-10 - 10 best.

    I think the ratings have to reflect that this Charlton side is the worst side we have meet this season...?

    Reina 7 solid. They never hit the target with anything of consequence.

    Finnan 6,5
    Good assist. Some woeful defending in the second half from him on the crosses from the left!

    Hyypiä 5,5
    Not only rotated but switched with Carra as well?! We looked unsettled for most of the match in the back4 against would could rightfully be described as a lame duck. Charlton is synonymous with relegation and had next to nothing to offer going foward. He threw the ball away in the first half and started some of the Charlton contra runs that way. Gave away a clumsy freekick just outside the box and passed poorly. I wasn't overly impressed tbh. Some woeful defending in the second half from him on the crosses from the left!

    Carra 6,5
    Solid. Same as always. The switching around did him no favours!

    Riise 5,5
    Didn't do much forward against a poor Charlton side. Should have been able to get passed Dennis Rommedahl who never was much of a defending RM.

    Pennnant 7
    Good crosses. Nice 'assists' to kuyt and others. Well in there Pennant!

    Alonso 8,5
    His best match on the final 1/3 so far this season. Well his best match all over the pitch to be correct. A joy to watch. Good shot on goal and great passing. Held it all together in a match where the other CM chose only to play for 20 mins. MOM

    Gerrard 6
    His first half against a abysmal Charlton was simply so far below par that I couldn't believe it. Came back in the 2nd half with some good efforts but if the first half was a 3 I'm being nice with a 6. A game is 90 mins. The goal helped!

    Gonzalez 7
    Good. Lively and played well. I like him!

    Kuyt 6
    As sharpe as a wooden spoon! A striker strikes and he looks less and less convincing to me! Yes, he ran a lot. But zero cool infront of goal and we need that more than a 'great workrate'!

    Belllamy 8
    Very good all round performance. Great goal and loads of assists to Kuyt. Good game!

    Rafa 7. Hard to criticise a 3-0 win away? If Charlton had scored on one of the 2 giga chances in the 2nd half 1-1 could easily have been the result or insult as it were. The BS rotatation crab in the back4 pisses me off. At least he had the courage to play 4-4-2. Still, we got away with a 3-0 win and he gets a 7.


    We were somewhere around Barstow on the edge of the desert when the drugs began to take hold.


    #2
    bellamy 8/10

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by Rocket View Post
      bellamy 8/10
      Yeah - I thought he did good


      We were somewhere around Barstow on the edge of the desert when the drugs began to take hold.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by CAD View Post
        Yeah - I thought he did good
        Bellers was awesome. He had their defence all over the place.
        The Crushing Machine MKII

        Comment


          #5
          I went to the game and was at pitch level. Saw everything Pennant did in the first half. 7 is generous.

          Alonso MOMO by a country mile closely followed by Bellers, Finnan, and SG.

          Sami is losing it big time.

          Comment


            #6
            I think today confirmed that Agger and Carra must be our first choice at the back
            "The definition of insanity is not running into the same wall again and again; it's expecting a different result every time you do it."

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Red_Al_77 View Post
              I went to the game and was at pitch level. Saw everything Pennant did in the first half. 7 is generous.

              Alonso MOMO by a country mile closely followed by Bellers, Finnan, and SG.

              Sami is losing it big time.
              I thought Alonso and Bellamy were tops today. Agree with you re Hyppia...shadow of his former self. But chump of the day has to be reserved for Riise. What a truly awful performance by him.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by desertscouser View Post
                I thought Alonso and Bellamy were tops today. Agree with you re Hyppia...shadow of his former self. But chump of the day has to be reserved for Riise. What a truly awful performance by him.
                Rommedahl and Young were running rings around him today. With Riise I'm inclined to think it's a one off although I'm a bit more concerned about Sami, will we be able to rely on him for long periods if needed? Can't see him being third choice next season the way things are going :|

                Great to see Xabi back into top form, and Bellamy starting to show what he can do. Gonzalez and Pennant are upping their levels bit by bit, you can see Speedy getting to grips with the English game and I think by then end of the season he'll have gone some way to justifying the hype that surrounded him on his arrival.
                Last edited by Red_Polo; 16-12-06, 06:51 PM.
                Like blood on iron

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Rocket View Post
                  bellamy 8/10
                  Signature updated
                  Like blood on iron

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by Red_Polo View Post
                    Signature updated
                    15 league goals i reckon he'll get

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Hyypia is losing his level of performance rapidly. This has to be his final year in the first team squad

                      We could have won 8 - 0, but also we could have concided two easily - Charlton are going down and lack alot of confidence, so luckily we didnt help to restore it

                      Carragher and Finnan were excellent, i thought

                      XA was MOM, and Gonzalez is getting better and better.

                      Bellamy and Kuyt are improving all the time, and we are looking like that team that was unbeaten for long stretches, but with a more potent goal threat with Bellers for Cisse and Kuyt for Crouch
                      We need better attacking players!

                      Torres aint enough

                      Rafas number #1 fan

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Reina 7 - Made a smart save early doors.

                        Finnan 6.5 - Assist and slightly below his own standards today.

                        Hyypiä 5 - Poor today, has been written off before though.

                        Carra 7 - solid display.

                        Riise 4 - Poor today, made the Charlton right side look better than they are.

                        Pennnant 6.5 - Got some decent balls in that went to red shirts. Not happy with the habit he has of pulling away from challenges though.

                        Alonso 9 - MOM. Calm and assured, pulled the strings and kept things ticking over for us.

                        Gerrard 6 - Would have gotten a five if he had not scored. Poor performance against a very poor team.

                        Gonzalez 7 - Good game, worked hard.


                        Kuyt 6 - Not his best game, but cannot be faulted for effort.


                        Belllamy 8 - Good performance, good goal, looked like the player we hope he is.
                        I don't hate people. I just feel better when they aren't around.


                        Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by Rocket View Post
                          15 league goals i reckon he'll get

                          I think he will finish on double figures in the league too.
                          I don't hate people. I just feel better when they aren't around.


                          Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Red_Al_77 View Post
                            I went to the game and was at pitch level. Saw everything Pennant did in the first half. 7 is generous.

                            Alonso MOMO by a country mile closely followed by Bellers, Finnan, and SG.

                            Sami is losing it big time.
                            He got us the penalty. He had an shot saved on the goalline and had several good runs and crosses in the first half. I think it's fair to say that we have seen worse from him. 7 might be a bit generous but he did ok


                            We were somewhere around Barstow on the edge of the desert when the drugs began to take hold.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by Red_Al_77 View Post

                              Alonso MOM by a country mile closely followed by Bellers, Finnan, and SG.
                              If you were a commentator, Private Eye would print that as in their Colemanballs

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X