I think it's going to be a Scotland win today and not just because Hogg's seeking revenge for me 'dissing' you Buzzo 
I don't really see that Jones has solved all the issues from last week (though if England start playing from minute one rather than minute 40 it's clearly going to be an improvement).
Youngs was awful last week and consistently took the wrong options. He's been good over the years but his time has come to move on. So I'm glad he's been dropped but I can't see that Heinz is much of an upgrade. There are far better in the Premiership, it's an absolute mystery why Jones thinks he should be the next cab off the rank.
Although Ford did ok against France I don't much care for this '2 distributors' thing with Farrell at 12. Pretty much all the teams use a blitz defence these days so the benefit of two 10's only really accrues if play is split and it almost never was. I'd far rather see a more traditional 12 in place.
Anthony Watson not being fit (again) is a blow and worse, means Furbank keeps his place. I'd move Daly back to FB (although his defence is a worry) and bring in Thorley. He's raw but he's a dynamic runner and provides a different dimension.
Equally, retaining Curry at 8 is a poor call. He's far more effective on the flank and we missed a big ball carrier like Hughes or Dombrandt last week with him there. And if Jones doesn't want one of those guys then he would have been better off recalling Simmonds who doesn't have physicality but does have an X factor: not many 8's set off from the back of a scrum at the pace of a back.
So not confident at all. If we lose it might be a good time for Jones to use the last three games to start introducing some more younger guys but I'm not sure that he would.
I don't really see that Jones has solved all the issues from last week (though if England start playing from minute one rather than minute 40 it's clearly going to be an improvement).
Youngs was awful last week and consistently took the wrong options. He's been good over the years but his time has come to move on. So I'm glad he's been dropped but I can't see that Heinz is much of an upgrade. There are far better in the Premiership, it's an absolute mystery why Jones thinks he should be the next cab off the rank.
Although Ford did ok against France I don't much care for this '2 distributors' thing with Farrell at 12. Pretty much all the teams use a blitz defence these days so the benefit of two 10's only really accrues if play is split and it almost never was. I'd far rather see a more traditional 12 in place.
Anthony Watson not being fit (again) is a blow and worse, means Furbank keeps his place. I'd move Daly back to FB (although his defence is a worry) and bring in Thorley. He's raw but he's a dynamic runner and provides a different dimension.
Equally, retaining Curry at 8 is a poor call. He's far more effective on the flank and we missed a big ball carrier like Hughes or Dombrandt last week with him there. And if Jones doesn't want one of those guys then he would have been better off recalling Simmonds who doesn't have physicality but does have an X factor: not many 8's set off from the back of a scrum at the pace of a back.
So not confident at all. If we lose it might be a good time for Jones to use the last three games to start introducing some more younger guys but I'm not sure that he would.
Comment