Cricket

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Zapater
    Dalglish
    • May 2007
    • 4813

    #3466
    Fair play, these two have cashed in on favourable conditions. On a different day SA would have nabbed atleast 2 more wickets yesterday for disciplined performance, but no complaints. Will need to bat really well to catch up.

    Originally posted by RichC
    Rabada banned from the next test
    Don't understand at all what is so offensive about his celebration, but it's typical. As I've said previously in this thread, if this system was in place before, Brett Lee would have missed every second game. Completely unnecessary. Not having a moan, but players from certain countries always seem to get a harsher sanction than others when the book is thrown at them. India, Australia and England get away with what they want and control everything.

    Presuming this isn't overturned, Bavuma will be sure to play the next game for 'transformation' reasons. So that will involve dropping a batsmen and adding a different bowler (keeping Paterson probably). Going into a test without a black player would cause mutiny despite the forced nature of the change. Unless Ngidi is fit again, at least that would be like for like.

    Comment

    • Shaggy
      Unidentified Rascal
      • Jul 2006
      • 135533

      #3467
      Agreed re Rabada. Don't see what was wrong with it.
      Thanks very much for being

      Comment

      • Chazza
        Des Lynam
        • Jan 2007
        • 31141

        #3468
        Stokes gone for 120.

        Comment

        • Alex
          Administrator
          • Jul 2006
          • 37058

          #3469
          Originally posted by Zapater
          Fair play, these two have cashed in on favourable conditions. On a different day SA would have nabbed atleast 2 more wickets yesterday for disciplined performance, but no complaints. Will need to bat really well to catch up.



          Don't understand at all what is so offensive about his celebration, but it's typical. As I've said previously in this thread, if this system was in place before, Brett Lee would have missed every second game. Completely unnecessary. Not having a moan, but players from certain countries always seem to get a harsher sanction than others when the book is thrown at them. India, Australia and England get away with what they want and control everything.

          Presuming this isn't overturned, Bavuma will be sure to play the next game for 'transformation' reasons. So that will involve dropping a batsmen and adding a different bowler (keeping Paterson probably). Going into a test without a black player would cause mutiny despite the forced nature of the change. Unless Ngidi is fit again, at least that would be like for like.
          Originally posted by Shaggy
          Agreed re Rabada. Don't see what was wrong with it.

          It was a build up of points apparently. So basically the same as totting up yellow cards and getting a ban for it. Didn't think it was bad anyway. Just a bit of needle.
          *Except Michael, who died.

          Comment

          • Zapater
            Dalglish
            • May 2007
            • 4813

            #3470
            So the demerit point is for "using language, actions or gestures which disparage or which could provoke an aggressive reaction from a batter upon his/her dismissal during an International Match".

            I mean that's open to interpretation but if you want to follow that to the letter of the law, there are dozens of incidents in each and every test which could be considered to do so. The way players regularly speak to their teammates about the opposition to avoid talking to them directly could easily facilitate an aggressive reaction. Disappointing that one of the best bowlers in the world wont get to play a home test for him. Thought the ICC's job is to promote and preserve test cricket. Not make it a poorer product.

            Although, Rabada isn't blameless, he has been called out on similar things in the past. Despite the situation being ridiculous, he should be aware that they're targeting him and he's been under the microscope for years. He shouldn't give the authorities the ammunition regardless of how marginal/circumstantial it is. Oh well, maybe a rest will do him some good.

            Just sets double standards - Brett Lee was a fiery competitor and Rabada is out of control. Different eras, I know but it doesn't sit well with me.

            Comment

            • Chazza
              Des Lynam
              • Jan 2007
              • 31141

              #3471
              Here comes the collapse.

              Buttler out for 1

              Comment

              • Zapater
                Dalglish
                • May 2007
                • 4813

                #3472
                Originally posted by Alex
                It was a build up of points apparently. So basically the same as totting up yellow cards and getting a ban for it. Didn't think it was bad anyway. Just a bit of needle.
                Indeed, it was the straw that broke the camels back, but I don't deem the incident befitting of it. But that's just my opinion, same as I didn't deem the Buttler incident noteworthy. In the previous tour when he told Stokes to **** off after getting him out, fair enough, that's unnecessarily aggressive. In this case, he was a bit close, but don't think it was that bad.

                Comment

                • Zapater
                  Dalglish
                  • May 2007
                  • 4813

                  #3473
                  On an amusing note, I think that Paterson must be one of the roughest players I've ever seen on an international cricket pitch. Check the teeth on the guy! Not the best haircut either.



                  Comment

                  • Shaggy
                    Unidentified Rascal
                    • Jul 2006
                    • 135533

                    #3474
                    Ollie Pope is here to stay huh? Fantastic. England line up suddenly shaping up pretty well I reckon.
                    Thanks very much for being

                    Comment

                    • Cormack74
                      Paisley
                      • Jan 2007
                      • 10533

                      #3475
                      Bell Jnr.

                      Comment

                      • RichC
                        Meh
                        • Jul 2006
                        • 37415

                        #3476
                        Nice early wicket this morning with Elgar going. 63-3

                        Comment

                        • RichC
                          Meh
                          • Jul 2006
                          • 37415

                          #3477
                          Bess takes another with du Plessie. 71-4

                          Comment

                          • Cormack74
                            Paisley
                            • Jan 2007
                            • 10533

                            #3478
                            A really good morning but the weather for the rest of today and tomorrow doesn't look great sadly.

                            Comment

                            • RichC
                              Meh
                              • Jul 2006
                              • 37415

                              #3479
                              4 wickets to bowl SA out for 1 run, that’s some real capitulation. Rain might be their saviour though. 15-0 after England forced the follow on.

                              Comment

                              • RichC
                                Meh
                                • Jul 2006
                                • 37415

                                #3480
                                1 down 3 wickets to go. Hopefully we can get this done quickly and take any weather concerns out of play.

                                Comment

                                Working...