FA Cup Final

[Nicey]

How is that not a straight red ... hes bottled that

[Exiled_red]

Player should be sent to the touchline with a yellow while the peno is being taken.
It it's scored, he comes back on.
If it's missed, the yellow becomes red.


Or better yet, just give the red if it's a ManU ****.

I wonder if people would miss the pen on purpose to play the rest of the game against 10 men, or if the keeper wouldn't try to save it so that they could keep 11.

[Nicey]

and he is the best ref in the lg

[Chris]

Pogba is vermin. Disgraceful decision by Oliver.

[Nicey]

Chelsea winning the FA cup would be perfect

[fidget]

I thought the new rule was clear, when you give a penalty you can't also give a red, as the pen is punishment enough... had that been outside of the box, or violent enoguh to warrant a red anywhere on the pitch, then yes, but no way in this situation.

you thought wrong mate - deliberate foul = red

[Norbs]

Pogba bought that, more **** reffing

Herrera's shot

[McDermotX]

I wonder if people would miss the pen on purpose to play the rest of the game against 10 men, or if the keeper wouldn't try to save it so that they could keep 11.

Aye. Make it a tactical play.
To be fair, if you could dictate a play go keep Jones out of your defence......I'd definitely be wanting my keeper to save it.

[Norbs]

Chelsea winning the FA cup would be perfect

I wouldn't go that far unless both teams suffer 7 ACLs in the process

[Exiled_red]

I thought the new rule was clear, when you give a penalty you can't also give a red, as the pen is punishment enough... had that been outside of the box, or violent enoguh to warrant a red anywhere on the pitch, then yes, but no way in this situation.

Is that the rule now? When did that change?

[Norbs]

Player should be sent to the touchline with a yellow while the peno is being taken.
It it's scored, he comes back on.
If it's missed, the yellow becomes red.


Or better yet, just give the red if it's a ManU ****.

Or, given the choice of a red or a penalty

[Fuzzy]

you thought wrong mate - deliberate foul = red

How was that a deliberate foul? Went for the ball but was miles off because he's **** Phil Jones.

Why would he do a deliberate foul in the 20th minute of the final if the rule is, as you say, a pen and a red?

[Exiled_red]

How was that a deliberate foul? Went for the ball but was miles off because he's **** Phil Jones.

Why would he do a deliberate foul in the 20th minute of the final if the rule is, as you say, a pen and a red?

The bit in bold might answer your last question

[fidget]

How was that a deliberate foul? Went for the ball but was miles off because he's **** Phil Jones.

Why would he do a deliberate foul in the 20th minute of the final if the rule is, as you say, a pen and a red?

Looked deliberate to the rest of us and thankfully I'm not privy to the workings of Phil Jones' mind




And your original post was

I thought the new rule was clear, when you give a penalty you can't also give a red, as the pen is punishment enough

which was wrong

[Fuzzy]

Looked deliberate to the rest of us and thankfully I'm not privy to the workings of Phil Jones' mind




And your original post was

which was wrong