Other Matches 22/23

[SB]

Villa players giving Stevie g a big **** you today!

Yeah there’s the new manager bounce & then there’s that

[Kenneth]

This one was interesting

[ame]https://twitter.com/theathleticuk/status/1584215402736807936[/ame]

MOTD consensus was that the keeper ****ed up and it wasn’t a foul. But i think it was a foul, or at least would be given as such in any other scenario, most of the time. Lloris was first to the ball, blocked from going for a second touch by an opposition player. The kind of thing salah doesn’t get but most players would. That it was the keeper and he made a bad call to come for it isn’t relevant.

[RichC]

Usually that's given as a foul, probably wrongly IMO as I think Keepers are given too much protection but 9/10 times that is given as a foul.

[ChesterDave]

From the one angle and distance it is difficult to tell if Wilson has deliberately blocked him or Loris is just too close to go round him and it is a coming together. Doesn't definitely appear as if he has changed direction or stopped dead in his tracks to block Loris (yes he stops moving forward towards but not as if he was moving across and stops that movement).

[wiw]

I thought on the closer angles/slow motion clips it looks as though Lloris bumps into him then flops to the ground to try and get a free kick

[Kenneth]

But he got the ball and was blocked and didn’t go down any more dramatically than any other outfield player would. It seems that a higher standard was set because he’s a goalkeeper and generally regarded as having made a bad call to come out to challenge for it.

[Buzzo]

Yeah I’m giving that as a goal. Loris ran into Wilson, he can’t just evaporate.

[Cerbie]

Yeah I’m giving that as a goal. Loris ran into Wilson, he can’t just evaporate.

FWIW

[RichC]

Yeah I’m giving that as a goal. Loris ran into Wilson, he can’t just evaporate.

I think it should have stood but it’s unusual to see keepers not being bailed out for stuff like that.

[ChesterDave]

Having now looked at the replay from a different angle its a definite foul from me. You can clearly see Wilson's arm come out to impede GK.

Frame by frame on PC/Laptop using , or . for those that didn't know

[ame="https://youtu.be/FrODfIpERV8?t=90"]Newcastle United move into the top four! 📈 | Tottenham 1-2 Newcastle | Premier League Highlights - YouTube[/ame]

[Kenneth]

It’s two players going head on for the same ball, one gets to it and the other doesn’t and blocks the progress of the one that does. Happens all the time and nobody brings out the ‘what can he do, he can’t disappear’ argument. The foul is caused by going for a ball that you don’t/can’t get to. I mentioned this one because I’m actually quite confused by much of the reaction to it.

[Buzzo]

It’s two players going head on for the same ball, one gets to it and the other doesn’t and blocks the progress of the one that does. Happens all the time and nobody brings out the ‘what can he do, he can’t disappear’ argument. The foul is caused by going for a ball that you don’t/can’t get to. I mentioned this one because I’m actually quite confused by much of the reaction to it.

Nah, you can write as much as you want - it’s a goal for me Clive.

[Norbs]

Yeah I’m giving that as a goal. Loris ran into Wilson, he can’t just evaporate.

Wasn't in the area either.

Goalies making challenges outside the safety of their area

[Kenneth]

Nah, you can write as much as you want - it’s a goal for me Clive.

It’s cool, you don’t have to agree. And I’m not cross, I’m just a bit disappointed.

[Buzzo]

It’s cool, you don’t have to agree. And I’m not cross, I’m just a bit disappointed.

I can have that affect on people.

I’ll do better