[bumped] Here's one for all the Luis haters.

[Speedy]

What would you say if i said Rooney had 41 assits in that time and Garcia 19?

He also appears to have taken one goal off Rooney and given it Garcia.

Rooney's having a bad year this year according to the press (i have seen enough of him to judge), yet he's got the most assists as a striker and is probably up there in the scoring charts.

I like Garcia, but comparing him to one of the country's best youngsters (albeit a dirty bluenose & honourable manc) is farcical.

[Neil Young]

I can't believe this argument is continuing. I mean, surely there is conclusive evidence out there that proves that Garcia is either really good or really bad.

[CJ]

bump

i hope no one thought it was our new no 7

[yamiedo]

If Rooney wasn't English, he'd never be as overhyped as he is. He's good, obviously, but he's not a genuinely great player. Not yet anyway.

He's also a complete cnut.

I found it amusing Rooney was linked with Barcelona during that contract saga, he would completely flop at Barca. I do think he is overrated too.

[vlahka]

Garcia was awesome. End of story.

[lickedlollipop]

There is only one Super Luis.

[Mattshark]

Garcia was awesome. End of story.

[RedAndWhite]

Garcia was awesome. End of story.

[CJ]

who ruined it and put bumped.

it took me a while to find an old thread that might trick some people. the fact kurtangle started it added to the pleasure

of course it didnt work at all.

hangs head in shame

[MrMichael]

That would have been me

[CJ]

right who do i complain to

who is of higher authority

i know, neil!!!