Scott Carson

[glynner]

He’s in good form for Villa, Martin O’Neill wants to keep him.
It would be good business to sell him at the end of the season imo

He’s in the middle of his Liverpool contract, and most likely won’t be happy playing long term second fiddle to Reina.

As a potential future English ‘keeper he would fetch a pretty penny- cash that could be put toward improving other areas of the team.

Time to let him go ?

[Shaggy]

Definitely time to let him go at the end of the season.

If Craig Gordon can fetch £9m, then we should be demanding similar for Carson. He only cost £750K, so for once it'd represent a great piece of transfer business.

[CharlieMansonsSquint]

Rafa played a blinder signing him to a long term deal then loaning him out.

We should get a good fee for him.

[thesilverfoxlfc]

Shame to see him go cause he's a decent keeper, too good to be a 2nd but if we get a massive fee for him then good business and we have a world class keeper already and hopefully Martin will develop and be close to first team in a few years thats if he can beat up Snipes to get on the bench

[wildman]

Definitely time to let him go at the end of the season.

If Craig Gordon can fetch £9m, then we should be demanding similar for Carson. He only cost £750K, so for once it'd represent a great piece of transfer business.

I think leeds may be entitled to some of whatt we make as think he had a sell on clause included within the contract prob 25%

[thesilverfoxlfc]

I think leeds may be entitled to some of whatt we make as think he had a sell on clause included within the contract prob 25%

The money they get should probably finish off their last payment of the transfer fee for Fowler

[Parm]

Rafa played a blinder signing him to a long term deal then loaning him out.

We should get a good fee for him.

shame, I do like the lad and think that he could have been a quality signing for us. But with Reina in good form and being so young, cant see Carson becoming a regular.

[MerseyCider]

The lad deserves a chance next season. Pepe still worries me at times, and id swap 3 other prem keepers for him in an instant.

[kurtangle01]

The lad deserves a chance next season. Pepe still worries me at times, and id swap 3 other prem keepers for him in an instant.

Carson's a good keeper, just not as good as Pepe. I wouldn't swap Pepe for any keeper around right now.

[AFII]

Carson's a good keeper, just not as good as Pepe. I wouldn't swap Pepe for any keeper around right now.

Sell Carson.

No point keeping a player that don't want to stay.

Hmmm......

£20m+£8m(Crouch)+£5m(Riise)+£10m(Carson)+£10m (Sissoko).....£53m. We will soon be able to sign Kaka

[red g]

The lad deserves a chance next season. Pepe still worries me at times, and id swap 3 other prem keepers for him in an instant.

yeh **** team unity and what reina has done for us so far, get him swapped now :whatever:

[Sir Bob]

Carson's a good keeper, just not as good as Pepe. I wouldn't swap Pepe for any keeper around right now.

Pepe's a good keeper but still has problems with crosses. He's good but not in Cech's class for my money. Cech along with Schmeicel (sp), Clemence and Southall is as good as I've seen

[dom9]

Pepe's a good keeper but still has problems with crosses. He's good but not in Cech's class for my money. Cech along with Schmeicel (sp), Clemence and Southall is as good as I've seen

You think?

I tyhink he is ridiculously commanding at crosses. He comes out and makes sure he gets there, even if there are five players in the way, he just flattens them. His punching of the ball is second to none.

I can't remember the last time he conceded from a cross that he came out for. Unlike the Reading game...

[Dhav]

Signed him for £750k.

We've got a £2m fee for loaning him out for the season? No doubt we got something similar from Charlton last season as well, we haven't paid his wages for 2 years and we'll probably sell him at the end of the season for at least £5m.

Blinding business if you ask me, especially as he'll get nowhere near a regular starting berth while Pepe's at Anfield.

Shame as he'd make a great number 2, but at least we'd have made a big profit on him.

[kurtangle01]

Pepe's a good keeper but still has problems with crosses. He's good but not in Cech's class for my money. Cech along with Schmeicel (sp), Clemence and Southall is as good as I've seen

Call me biased and others might not agree but I actually can't think of a better keeper currently playing. Cech's a class keeper but even he makes the odd mistake. imho, Cech and Pepe are the best two in Europe but I'd still go for Pepe.