Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Who's the best Ex-Liverpool player pundit/writer/commentator??

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Page of 4
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
Previous 1 2 3 4 template Next
    #1

    Who's the best Ex-Liverpool player pundit/writer/commentator??

    Whether they do punditry, write a column or commentate......

    Jim Beglin?
    Lawro?
    Alan Hansen?
    Barry Venison?
    Jamie Redknapp?
    Ronnie Whelan?
    Jan Molby?
    Jason McAteer?
    Steve McManaman?
    Gary Mac?
    Ray Houghton?
    Ian Rush?
    Phil Thompson?
    David Fairclough?
    Alan Kennedy?
    Graeme Souness?
    Kenny Dalglish?
    John Toshack?
    Gary Gillespie?
    John Aldridge?
    Nigel Spackman?
    Paul Walsh?
    When you feel like you're done, you are not alone........
    Tags: None
    #2
    I enjoy listening to Souness, Gary Mac, Lawro, Hansen and Aldridge
    Last edited by thesilverfoxlfc; 11-10-07, 06:38 PM.
    When you feel like you're done, you are not alone........

    Comment

      #3
      Gary Mac.

      Comment

        #4
        Hansen.

        Comment

          #5
          Fairclough for me, deffo. he does the reserve games and also commentates for today fm most saturdays in ireland.....easy to listen to and honest
          Referee Lubos Michel said: “If my assistant referee had not signalled a goal, I would have given a penalty, and sent off goalkeeper Petr Cech.”

          Comment

            #6
            Ray Houghton.Extremely positive and never ever slates us.
            Oh the man is a midfield maestro
            and his passes are sooo delightful
            everyone wants to know
            Alonso Alonso Alonso

            Comment

              #7
              Originally posted by Jan Molby View Post
              Fairclough for me, deffo. he does the reserve games and also commentates for today fm most saturdays in ireland.....easy to listen to and honest
              sorry mate i find fairclough attrocious tbh,i find he fails to even complete a sentence properly,kind of stops mid sentence because he cant find the word hes looking for.

              souness is good on the rte panel,you cant fault hansen and i dont mind jim beglin.
              You two scousers are always yapping,I'm gonna show you some serious rapping.
              I come from Jamaica,my name is John Barnes,When I do my thing the crowd go bananas.

              Comment

                #8
                Originally posted by thesilverfoxlfc View Post
                I enjoy listening to Souness, Gary Mac, Lawro, Hansen and Aldridge
                apart from Lawro
                Its times like these we learn to live again FF

                Comment

                  #9
                  Originally posted by redlancer View Post
                  apart from Lawro
                  lawro does my head in,i love the way hes english again.
                  but saying that,hes not bad at his job.
                  You two scousers are always yapping,I'm gonna show you some serious rapping.
                  I come from Jamaica,my name is John Barnes,When I do my thing the crowd go bananas.

                  Comment

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Rafa Shankly View Post
                    sorry mate i find fairclough attrocious tbh,i find he fails to even complete a sentence properly,kind of stops mid sentence because he cant find the word hes looking for.

                    souness is good on the rte panel,you cant fault hansen and i dont mind jim beglin.
                    understand, but i find him honest and not afraid to say that the team is playing
                    poorly.
                    Souness is good on rte, but thats kinda my point, compare him on rte to him on sky???? totaly different imho, but i do accept ur point.
                    can't stand hansen by the way
                    Referee Lubos Michel said: “If my assistant referee had not signalled a goal, I would have given a penalty, and sent off goalkeeper Petr Cech.”

                    Comment

                      #11
                      gillespie is good on the lfc channel also aldo he's a die hard red great to listen to as for that manc supporting thatched roof head lawro.............
                      "What are ya gonna do, release the dogs or the bees or the dogs with bees in their mouths so when they bark they shoot bees at you"
                      "In america 1st you get the sugar, then you get the power, then you get the women"

                      Comment

                        #12
                        Originally posted by niallers1 View Post
                        gillespie is good on the lfc channel also aldo he's a die hard red great to listen to as for that manc supporting thatched roof head lawro.............
                        Referee Lubos Michel said: “If my assistant referee had not signalled a goal, I would have given a penalty, and sent off goalkeeper Petr Cech.”

                        Comment

                          #13
                          Originally posted by thesilverfoxlfc View Post
                          Whether they do punditry, write a column or commentate......

                          Jim Beglin? Desperate, always moaning - an armchair manager with a salary.
                          Lawro? Generally inoffensive - if that's a good thing...
                          Alan Hansen? Too cliche'd for me ...grit, determination, yadya, yadya. Knows he's not funny either - becomes self concscious.
                          Barry Venison? Don't know.
                          Jamie Redknapp? Don't know.
                          Ronnie Whelan? Not great
                          Jan Molby? Don't know.
                          Jason McAteer? Is he punditing!!!!
                          Steve McManaman? As above!!!!!!
                          Gary Mac? Don't know.
                          Ray Houghton? Possibly the worst co-commentator on TV. Mr 'could've/should've'. Like Beglin, never knows when to shut up. Always see's the worst side of a situation.
                          Ian Rush? Not bad on SSN when I've seen him...
                          Phil Thompson? I think he's a chancer. Seems to be making up his points as he speaks.
                          David Fairclough? Okay on radio.
                          Alan Kennedy? Don't know.
                          Graeme Souness? Not bad on RTE - but he does have to deal with the best football pundits on TV in these Isles....
                          Kenny Dalglish? Don't know.
                          John Toshack? Not great - difficult to watch.
                          Gary Gillespie? Don't know.
                          John Aldridge? Not great either.
                          Nigel Spackman? Don't know.
                          Paul Walsh? Good on SSN, I think.
                          So, Walsh, Souness, Rush.

                          Frank
                          Francis.

                          ...."Any team that concedes as few goals as we concede is going to be tough to play against..." - Fernando Torres on Liverpool

                          And when I say 'play Gerrard on the left', I mean on the left

                          A defensive mid for £18m?

                          Comment

                            #14
                            I cant stand Phil Thompson him and Redknapp get on my nerves terrible pundits
                            Last edited by thesilverfoxlfc; 12-10-07, 12:56 AM.
                            When you feel like you're done, you are not alone........

                            Comment

                              #15
                              Souness was excellent for RTE during the World Cup last year.

                              He always talks sense but has trouble keeping the wood nymph Dunphy from disappearing up his hole.

                              Disagree about Houghton - I always think his views are very fair. I don't think he is being negative, he's just not afraid to speak his mind instead of blabbering on with inanities and banal cliches like Lawro.

                              Haven't heard Ronnie Whelan do much commentary but his column is always fair and incisive.
                              A humble guy with healthy desire.

                              Comment

                              Previous 1 2 3 4 template Next
                              Working...
                              X