Originally posted by DJS
View Post
What do you think our players are currently worth?
I dont mean how much would a tabloid hype their values to, i mean what would they genuinely fetch on the market if they were sold?
IMO:
Reina - £11m - Really hard to judge with keepers 11m is a fair price but I think we'd get more if it was Real for instance
Finnan - £1.5m Too low i'd say around 3m, even with age taken into account
Agger - £9m at least 10m and probe even more
Carra - £6m I think Carra would fetch more than 6m, particularly in somewhere like Italy where they seem to rate him, unlike this country
Riise - £4m At least 6m I think
Arbeloa - £3m - Fair
Aurelio - £3m - Fair
Hyypia - £1m - Fair
Kewell - zero (contract up in Summer 2008) - Fair
Gerrard - £38m - maybe slightly overpriced but too hard to judge
Torres - £28m - ditto
Voronin - £3m - hard to judge at this stage, I think could be looking at 5m in a few months time
Benayoun - £5m - Fair
Alonso - £9m - ludicrous, he certainly has gone down in value, double that would be more like his true figure
Crouch - £10m - Fair
Pennant - £4.5m - Maybe slightly low but prob no more than 5m
Kuyt - £7m - Fair (on current form)
Babel - £10m - hard to say
Masherano - £17m - Fair
Lucas - £5m - hard to say
Sissoko - £5m - Fair, but I think we could get more for him
Not bothering with the bit part players...
Any thoughts? Remember, this isnt what YOU might think they're worth, with your little biased red hat on
It's what their market value would be...
I dont mean how much would a tabloid hype their values to, i mean what would they genuinely fetch on the market if they were sold?
IMO:
Reina - £11m - Really hard to judge with keepers 11m is a fair price but I think we'd get more if it was Real for instance
Finnan - £1.5m Too low i'd say around 3m, even with age taken into account
Agger - £9m at least 10m and probe even more
Carra - £6m I think Carra would fetch more than 6m, particularly in somewhere like Italy where they seem to rate him, unlike this country
Riise - £4m At least 6m I think
Arbeloa - £3m - Fair
Aurelio - £3m - Fair
Hyypia - £1m - Fair
Kewell - zero (contract up in Summer 2008) - Fair
Gerrard - £38m - maybe slightly overpriced but too hard to judge
Torres - £28m - ditto
Voronin - £3m - hard to judge at this stage, I think could be looking at 5m in a few months time
Benayoun - £5m - Fair
Alonso - £9m - ludicrous, he certainly has gone down in value, double that would be more like his true figure
Crouch - £10m - Fair
Pennant - £4.5m - Maybe slightly low but prob no more than 5m
Kuyt - £7m - Fair (on current form)
Babel - £10m - hard to say
Masherano - £17m - Fair
Lucas - £5m - hard to say
Sissoko - £5m - Fair, but I think we could get more for him
Not bothering with the bit part players...
Any thoughts? Remember, this isnt what YOU might think they're worth, with your little biased red hat on
It's what their market value would be...
RAFA 
Comment