Why Keep taking Keane off?

[MrMichael]

Bellamy offered more than Keane has so far.

I'd disagree, Bellamy had a very slow start remember, very like Keane looked like he was trying too hard. I'd be pretty sure that if you worked out Bellamy's goals & assists at this point compared to Keane, the latter's would be better.

Personally I rate Bellamy too, shame he's such a ****.

. If you recall, they had 4 very good strikers .

No, they had 3 good ones and Darren Bent

[Harv]

Bellamy offered more than Keane has so far.

**** off he has

[Elvoz]

[QUOTE=MrMichael;1199860]I'd disagree, Bellamy had a very slow start remember, very like Keane looked like he was trying too hard. I'd be pretty sure that if you worked out Bellamy's goals & assists at this point compared to Keane, the latter's would be better.

Personally I rate Bellamy too, shame he's such a ****.





tis why your me fave mod

[Mike]

4 assists is good so far. I think he adds a lot of game intelligence to the attacking setup. I'd like to see Yossi and Keane working together. I think that could work too.

Yossi is complete and utter crap, he has shown that whenever he plays for us.

[Reece]

Yossi is complete and utter crap, he has shown that whenever he plays for us.

I don't think that is really fair. He has produced some good moments for us, including at least one important winning goal. But for me he is terribly inconsistent and ridiculously light weight. He does seem to perform better in Europe.
In fact I guess he reminds me a lot of Luis Garcia. I know which I'd prefer though.

[Sarb]

Yossi just doesn't seem to have a clue what to do when he has to make that final decision whether to cross or shoot. Invariably he just tries to turn inside, outside and then loses the ball

However, he's probably affected due to not playing continuously. That's a problem for him and frankly, I don't think he's good enough to start a game for us, and for me not a good option off the bench either. He'd be good at a mid-table team where he gets to play consistently.

[theluckycharm]

cus he's ****e! lol

[Mike]

Tries to do too much when he plays and it costs us the ball.

Also he does not get back to defend which hacks me off, i know riera does not do this as much as kuyt but still at least riera makes up for it.

[Kenneth]

Yossi is complete and utter crap, he has shown that whenever he plays for us.

A complete and utter crap hattrick he scored not too long ago too.

He's not good enough, I agree, but let's no go overboard.



And Keane doesn't play 90 mins because he's utter crap.

[Reece]

A complete and utter crap hattrick he scored not too long ago too.

He's not good enough, I agree, but let's no go overboard.



And Keane doesn't play 90 mins because he's utter crap.

[Mike]

Personally, i would pick El Zhar over Yossi.
This season yossi looks piss poor and needs to sort himself out asap. Put him in the carling cup starting XI.

[Kenneth]

Personally, i would pick El Zhar over Yossi.
This season yossi looks piss poor and needs to sort himself out asap. Put him in the carling cup starting XI.

I think I'd pick El Zhar over Keane tbh.

[Skillz]

Keane was bought as a partner for Torres and a quality addition to our forwards when Torres isn't there. He is doing ok and is improving even though Torres isn't there.

We are undefeated until he went off against Spurs and we lost our mojo.

[Parm]

Could be the case of trying too hard to impress in the limited time he's got. Thought he did brilliantly for the goal on Sunday but too often at the moment I find myself thinking that he's trying to play an eye-catching flick or a killer pass that isn't quite on.

I still think he'll come good - a quality player at Spurs should never become a lesser player at LFC.

yup, he is trying too hard and that his making his touch anxious and poor. if he was relaxed in the knoweldge that Rafa has full confidence in him (ala Torres and Kuyt) then I am sure he would be ok

[dww]

I think too much is being made of this to be honest. I think he has shown some good touches and movement but is over thinking things and not fully confident. He will get confidence by getting some goals and playing well. He comes off after a 65 minutes or whatever as we have strong options to change things centrally and worse options wide when we need to alter our attacking style IMO.

If he isn't mentally strong enough to fight to find the form we need him in to stay on for 90 minutes then he was a poor signing (or at least an over expensive one). I think he is good enough to come through, only time will tell.