Lee Dixon with some nice observations

[massdebate]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/football/eng_prem/7959027.stm

Good to see Reina's distribution given some recognition. He really is immense in that regard.

[DannyMan2006]

He's the best keeper in the world when it comes to distribution. Also excels at positioning and organisation of the back 4, aided superbly by Carra.

His weakness is his lack of agility and he is unlikely to make too many amazing saves over the course of a season such as a Buffon or Casillias. But no one is perfect and I wouldn't swap him for anyone. A very likeable character too and big help with morale I'd suggest as highlighted by many in the summer for Spain.

[saj]

He's the best keeper in the world when it comes to distribution. Also excels at positioning and organisation of the back 4, aided superbly by Carra.

His weakness is his lack of agility and he is unlikely to make too many amazing saves over the course of a season such as a Buffon or Casillias. But no one is perfect and I wouldn't swap him for anyone. A very likeable character too and big help with morale I'd suggest as highlighted by many in the summer for Spain.

I always thought his agility was amazing and one of his strongest points. Look at the save from the Carew header on Sunday. The save he made against Harewood in extra time in the 2006 FA cup final. He made a save last year I think in Europe which was one of the greatest saves I have ever seen (unfortunately I can't remember the team it was against). Casillas has far more shots to deal with in one games than Reina would have in 2/3 games and it's inevitable that he's going to pull of more saves. That's why some keepers look world class at ****e teams (even though they concede more goals) - the minute they sign for a better team where they less shots to deal with and need to concentrate/stay awake for longer (as they may go 70 minutes without having anything to do), they tend to become become more error prone. Ben Foster is a good example of this and also Kusczak

[Shaggy]

Yep I reckon he's extremely agile.

[red g]

i wouldnt swap him with anyone in the world.....his distribution is the closest thing i have seen to schmeicel. he is a truly phenomenal keeper

[Chris]

His weakness is his lack of agility

I've always thought it was one of his main strengths! The Adebayor header he tipped on to the post when we beat Arsenal 4-1 at Anfield (Crouch hattrick) always stands out, it was one of the most astonishing saves ive ever seen. I also think its part of the reason he's so great at saving penalties, even if its right in the corner theres a chance he'll get there because of his agility.

[simey85]

I think his only weaknesses are is his ability in the air and having no hair!

[Ben_Itez]

Wouldnt swap him for any other keeper in the world.

In fact, i think we can say that about a few of our players in their respective positions. Gerrard, Torres, Xabi, Mascher and personally i think Agger will go on to be one of the best defenders in the world.

[wiw]

Agreed his agility is one of his strong points.

I just love watching him. His physique, (on the ball) skills and balance are fantastic compared to people like Cech, Gomes etc who look like they have 2 left feet. He's got a long body rather than long legs I think, which helps I guess

[DannyMan2006]

I always thought his agility was amazing and one of his strongest points. Look at the save from the Carew header on Sunday. The save he made against Harewood in extra time in the 2006 FA cup final. He made a save last year I think in Europe which was one of the greatest saves I have ever seen (unfortunately I can't remember the team it was against). Casillas has far more shots to deal with in one games than Reina would have in 2/3 games and it's inevitable that he's going to pull of more saves. That's why some keepers look world class at ****e teams (even though they concede more goals) - the minute they sign for a better team where they less shots to deal with and need to concentrate/stay awake for longer (as they may go 70 minutes without having anything to do), they tend to become become more error prone. Ben Foster is a good example of this and also Kusczak

Yep I reckon he's extremely agile.

I've always thought it was one of his main strengths! The Adebayor header he tipped on to the post when we beat Arsenal 4-1 at Anfield (Crouch hattrick) always stands out, it was one of the most astonishing saves ive ever seen. I also think its part of the reason he's so great at saving penalties, even if its right in the corner theres a chance he'll get there because of his agility.

I disagree. He does make some good saves yes, but not as many out of this world saves as a Calsillas or Buffon, both of whom play with top teams at International and club level.

I just think that when I'm watching Reina he makes saves I would expect him to make and not many that I think are amazing to see. The fact he has conceded so few goals shows he makes up for it in other areas - his positioning for one, the most important attribute a keeper can have. But there have been very rare occasions where watching Reina i have said "How did he save that?"

Just my opinion, and as I said I wouldn't swap him for anyone.

[Winstonio]

I disagree. He does make some good saves yes, but not as many out of this world saves as a Calsillas or Buffon, both of whom play with top teams at International and club level.

I just think that when I'm watching Reina he makes saves I would expect him to make and not many that I think are amazing to see. The fact he has conceded so few goals shows he makes up for it in other areas - his positioning for one, the most important attribute a keeper can have. But there have been very rare occasions where watching Reina i have said "How did he save that?"

Just my opinion, and as I said I wouldn't swap him for anyone.

I dont understand?

He doesnt need to make the saves, he doesnt dive when he doesnt need to and he does what he has to.

Doesnt mean he isnt agile, which he clearly is when you look at the saves he has made.

[red g]

I disagree. He does make some good saves yes, but not as many out of this world saves as a Calsillas or Buffon, both of whom play with top teams at International and club level.

I just think that when I'm watching Reina he makes saves I would expect him to make and not many that I think are amazing to see. The fact he has conceded so few goals shows he makes up for it in other areas - his positioning for one, the most important attribute a keeper can have. But there have been very rare occasions where watching Reina i have said "How did he save that?"

Just my opinion, and as I said I wouldn't swap him for anyone.

i think its more down to Reina's superb positioning, look at it from a flip side.....how many times do you think to yourself, casillas/buffon would have saved that when reina lets a gaol in

[squaddie]

I disagree. He does make some good saves yes, but not as many out of this world saves as a Calsillas or Buffon, both of whom play with top teams at International and club level.

I just think that when I'm watching Reina he makes saves I would expect him to make and not many that I think are amazing to see. The fact he has conceded so few goals shows he makes up for it in other areas - his positioning for one, the most important attribute a keeper can have. But there have been very rare occasions where watching Reina i have said "How did he save that?"

Just my opinion, and as I said I wouldn't swap him for anyone.

Have to disagree with you there. I think the likes of Calsillas and Buffon have more saves to make due to the league they play in, which would obviously lead to seeing more of them. But thats not to say thier any better, in fact I would says Reina's agility is just as good due to the fact that he wont have to make a save all game but still be totally aware and ready to commit himself when needed. Guy is a ledge.

[RedReet]

I just think that when I'm watching Reina he makes saves I would expect him to make and not many that I think are amazing to see.

Does he miss shots that you expect him to save though?

[Jaymo]

For a fella who is 14 stone. He is an extremely good goalkeeper. Strong, yes he did look suspect at dealing with crosses at first.. but he has come on leaps and bounds.

His speed off his line is another great asset he has. If a striker gets past Carra you can be sure Reina will be on top of the ball in no time at all.

Reina makes some brilliant saves, Pederson against blackburn away is just one of these.

all in all no doubt the best keeper we have had in a long time, and im thoroughly glad we have him.