Best ever Liverpool 11

[brikkis]

.............Clemence

.....Neal Carra Hansen Riise

Keegan Gerrard Souness Barnes

...........Dalglish Rush

[Redspin]

Who would you choose?

Clemence

Neil Carragher Hansen Jones

McManaman Gerrard Souness Barnes

Dalglish Rush

As ever with these things it depends on your age. Whilst I've been watching Liverpool (1964 onwards) I can tell you categorically that Neal, Carragher, Jones and McManaman wouldn't get within a million miles of Liverpool's best XI.

Smith was an incomparably superior RB to Neal and was also a far superior CB to Carragher, as were Yeats, Lawrenson and Gillespie for that matter. Hughes was incalculably better than Jones at LB (I assume you mean Joey as Rob was RB - but he was much better than either). The luxury player that was McManaman had several superiors on the right, Callaghan springs to mind instantly, but there ar several other better candidates than McManaman

[Los Rojos]

Clemence
Jones
Hansen
Hughes
Nicol
Gerrard
Molby
Souness
Barnes
Rush
Dalglish

[Los Rojos]

(Ask me next week and it could be different but...Clemence,Hansen,Souness,Barnes and King Kenny will always be there)

Same here mate (but Rushie would always make my team as well)

[Liver_Andy77]

------------------------Ray Clemence------------------------
Phil Neal----Alan Hansen-----Mark Lawrenson-----Emlyn Hughes
Kevin Keegan---Steven Gerrard---Graeme Souness---John Barnes
---------------Kenny Dalglish------Ian Rush---------------------

Subs: Bruce Grobbelaar, Steve Nicol, Phil Thompson, Jan Molby, Steve Heighway, Robbie Fowler

[BobTheCharmer]

Brucie
Nicol
Hansen
Hughes
Lawro
R Kennedy
Souness
Barnes
McMahon
Dalglish
Rush

Subs;
Gerrard
Fowler
Neale
Clemo
Keegan

[JRG]

I would put Callaghan in any team along with Chris Lawler, Peter Thompson and Roger Hunt also deserve more consideration.

Difficult anorak sort of question this.

[BobTheCharmer]

I would put Callaghan in any team along with Chris Lawler, Peter Thompson and Roger Hunt also deserve more consideration.

Difficult anorak sort of question this.

more to do with your age I guess. Being 30, they were before my time.

Team of 87,88,89 was my favourite.

[Charlie_B]

Arphexad
Song
Otsemebor
Xavier
Babb
Camara
Diao
Ince
Pennant (C)
Heskey
Diouf

[BobTheCharmer]

Arphexad
Song
Otsemebor
Xavier
Babb
Camara
Diao
Ince
Pennant (C)
Heskey
Diouf

whats the point of that?

[Los Rojos]

whats the point of that?

And very harsh on a few of the players, i.e. Camara who was a star and Pennant, who may well become a star in the near future.

[Parm]

Clemence

Lawrenson Carra Hansen

Molby
McDermott, Souness Barnes

Dalglish
Rush Keegan

[The_weatherman]

whats the point of that?

These are all black I would think probably relating to another thread

[Fan65]

Only one mention of Thommo, disappointing as he was a great CB in his era.

This is too difficult to call really

Just look at these Strikers... Roger Hunt, Ian Rush, Robbie Fowler ,Kenny Dalglish, Kevin Keegan, John Toshack, Peter Beardsley Ian St John,

all great in their day ,how do you pick the best....Ok it's the RAF for me then.

Fave Winger for me...Stevie Heighway..by a mile.

Fave Midfielder for me... Ronnie Whelan...so skillful and tough

Fave CB for me... Alan Hansen ..superb

Fave FB

Some who should have made it but didn't.. Bobby Graham, Alun Evans, Emile Hesky

[Charlie_B]

These are all black I would think probably relating to another thread

Ding ding ding!