Originally posted by Charly
View Post
That is something we need to stop doing. We cannot compare Slot or anyone else that comes in to Klopp.
We are not getting another Klopp. He, like Shankly and like Paisley, is a once off type of football manager. Could throw Kenny in there too.
Those guys that tick every single box as a coach, as a manager, as a personality and as a human being are so so rare. All you can do is enjoy their stays and cherish the time you get to watch them being them.
We have had other managers that ticked some of the boxes needed to be that close to perfect man for the club and city, but none ticked all the boxes like that quartet imo.
Compared to Klopp any manager we get is a step down on at least some levels.
We need to take all the new guys on their own merits. Slot for his part has had one amazing season and one poor season. That's what Slot gets to own and be judged upon. What Klopp did or what Klopp built does not matter in relation to anyone else as without Klopp those things were always going to be transitory.
We got lucky in the period from Shankly to Kenny (with Joe in there too) in that we had a crazy run of high calibre managers and men. Just look though at the run from Souness to Brendan Rogers. Two very good managers in there (Ged and Rafa) and the rest were a mixed bag, but no ticking of all the boxes on and off the pitch. No guy that made us the very best on the pitch and that felt like he was the very best type of person off of it at the same time. We had guys that were the latter without the former and a lot of guys that were neither.
Some time in the future we are going to be lucky enough to see another amazing personality and manager in charge of the team but it might take two seasons it might take twenty seasons before we see that again.
I'm just glad I got to live through our Klopp era, but it has ended and experience has taught that making comparisons to genuine GOATs of the past only ends with the tainting of the present if those comparisons are being made in a "why can we not have the same right now?" kind of way
And that is imo of course.
yeah can't disagree with any of that.
Leave a comment: