Luis Garcia

[Red_Polo]

I'm coffee total & teetotal! Sorry, couldn't resist.

LOL I've made that mistake before haha

[MrsB]

I just want to marry him...

You can have him.

[fowlen]

Lil Luis, may be a liability at times, but he has been one our most important players over the last two seasons.
He seems to play brilliantly and lift the team when it is needed, and correct me if I am wrong, but I have never seen the opposition score when he has lost possession etc etc.

He has an enormous heart, and plays with the passion that I expect to see from anyone wearing red.

As much as Luis has frustrated me at times, i think we're a better team on the majority of occasions that he is in the side.

Maybe he needs to stay a little further upfield and not play as deeply as he has...

[Jayesh87]

When will people start to realise Luis Garcia is simply not good enough?

He's slow
Lightweight
Erratic
Terrible passer of the ball
Careless
Indisciplined

But for the occasional pieces of magic he is a complete liability, forever giving the ball and in suicidal positions, i love the lad for his passion and committement but he's still more cons than pros about him.

I know 'on his day' he's one of very few creative players we have but like i say that's not enough imo, certainly not enough to warrant a starting birth at a top 4 side.

Maybe not sell, keep him as a squaddy although if we get a decent bid, i'd have no qualms about letting Luis go.

Don't be so silly!!

Luis is a very important player for us, especially in europe and at home. He scores do many important goals for us and is a flair player and can make something happen out of nothing! Something we lack at the moment imo! Yea he can be annoying at times but i would never sell him!

[friedk]

Take away the usual crap about the faults of Luis Garcia and look at the facts

1. Always good for more than 10 goals a season
2. Capable of moments of sheer inspiration and jaw dropping brilliance
3. One of our top players for assists
4. Delivers in the big games
5. Plays the game with flair and tries to entertain the fans

I would never want to sell him.

[carheex]

When will people start to realise Luis Garcia is simply not good enough?

He's slow
Lightweight
Erratic
Terrible passer of the ball
Careless
Indisciplined

But for the occasional pieces of magic he is a complete liability, forever giving the ball and in suicidal positions, i love the lad for his passion and committement but he's still more cons than pros about him.

I know 'on his day' he's one of very few creative players we have but like i say that's not enough imo, certainly not enough to warrant a starting birth at a top 4 side.

Maybe not sell, keep him as a squaddy although if we get a decent bid, i'd have no qualms about letting Luis go.

Yeah, let's get rid of gerrard, carragher, kuyt, crouch and sissoko aswell!!!

[Mattshark]

Fair enough, you're a big fan of Luis, i used to be, in his first season i was very close to getting his name on the home top, i'm glad i didn't, just caught on last season that this lad isn't good enough for us.
Thought he was just taking time to settle in to the English style of play but no he' still giving the ball away as much now as when he first arrived, still wasting glorious chances, still trying the impossible, still pansying about and just generally being a fcuking liability.

Errrm Garcia in last 10 passes before of play never once led to us conceding a goal and he was involved in the cration of more goals than any other prem player last season..............
Fool.

[Red_Al_77]

He adds the unexpected. He also scores a lot of goals. He has to stay and I'd be mightily unimpressed if he were sold.

[Nic83]

He's still a frustrating little ****er though, is our Luis.

[Morph]

This thread is pointless, Garcia shouldn't go anywhere, he up there with Gerrard in having the ability to change games. That means he stays.

end of dicsussion

[mersey86]

This thread is pointless, Garcia shouldn't go anywhere, he up there with Gerrard in having the ability to change games. That means he stays.

end of dicsussion

Thanks for clearing that up. We were getting really confused for a while.

[Diego]

love the little *******, he creates so much, always gets him self into a goalscoring opportunity whilst others can, but when the team is under achieving then so is he, he's so good when the players around him are on form, assiting linking up wicked crosses mad play-making, but he usually does not shine and carry on by him self, when we get into our rhythm, everybody will love him again, cause he'll start to deliver the magic again...

[carheex]

He's still a frustrating little ****er though, is our Luis.

name me one player who isn't?

[Morph]

Thanks for clearing that up. We were getting really confused for a while.

Glad to help

[Farside]

[QUOTE=dww]When will people like you notice that he has been just about our best player this season.

How do you come up with that? And I don't buy into this "big game player" thing. You are either good enough for all games or you are a squad player. And that's what Garcia is, a squad player. His first touch is usually ace and his second is usually woeful. If we get about 4or 5 mil for him we should take it.