Andy Carroll

[meffin]

Meffin in response to me suggesting we should take £40m + Sturridge
http://www.est1892.co.uk/forums/show...postcount=2444

Haha **** off.

To be fair that was 2 years ago, he wasn't as good then

[Mostar]

Carroll Goal vs Swansea

[ame="http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xx8bca_carroll-west-ham_sport"]Carroll (West Ham) - Vìdeo Dailymotion[/ame]

[Gibbo]

Looks ****ing miles better now he has cut his hair.

Never fit us unfortunately.

[Vermilion]

David Sullivan:



Doesn't sound like they have the money to sign Carroll.

So long as he scores the odd few goals and makes himself an absolute nuiscance for opponents as he did today, then i don't think we'll have trouble selling him.

There will always be teams looking for that type of player in the Premiership imo. Just hope he performs well from now till the end of the season, so we can hopefully get the best price possible.

[Liverpool]

I think we'll eays get 12-15m for him, id be concerned signing him for this fitness/lack of games. Must be over 2 years since hes had a proper run of 7-8 games or more

[Leyton388]

Would love too see him go on a run of games scoring a few goals. He looked good during the end of last season. If he has a good run now until the end of the season and If we don't get a good offer in the summer i would like him too come back and be our plan B. Thats if Borini doesn't do much for the rest of the season.

[Icon]

I'd like to see him do well, and LFC take him back.

[Mattshark]

I'd like to see him do well, and LFC take him back.

He will never be good enough. He is technically inept and positionally awful. He works fine for a long ball team. He would be awful for us.

[Liverpool]

He will never be good enough. He is technically inept and positionally awful. He works fine for a long ball team. He would be awful for us.

his positioning was fine for newcastle, wasnt til he came to us that he had no idea what to do

[Mattshark]

his positioning was fine for newcastle, wasnt til he came to us that he had no idea what to do

It wasn't they just used him to play a very rudimentary style of football. He is simply a very mediocre player who should never have been bought.

[Liverpool]

It wasn't they just used him to play a very rudimentary style of football. He is simply a very mediocre player who should never have been bought.

I think Newcastle mix it up well, not a million miles away from Everton this season

[Icon]

We have virtually no aerial threat, and Andy is one. Given a run to get fit and confident he'd do well.
We will not carry a vast array if attacking options that cause problems for opposition defenses relying on pass, pass, pass along the ground over and over. Teams are already reading us as we pose the same attacking threat game after game.

Just my thoughts.

[Mattshark]

We have virtually no aerial threat, and Andy is one. Given a run to get fit and confident he'd do well.
We will not carry a vast array if attacking options that cause problems for opposition defenses relying on pass, pass, pass along the ground over and over. Teams are already reading us as we pose the same attacking threat game after game.

Just my thoughts.

He is also ****ing **** at football. Doesn't matter how long we give him, he will never be good enough and would a huge detriment to the team because he is so one dimensional and unintelligent.

Tall player for the sake of a tall player.

[BigChief]

Please God let Carroll score another 5 goals at least this season. Then West Ham might actually cough up 17 million for him. Amen.

[RichC]

He is also ****ing **** at football. Doesn't matter how long we give him, he will never be good enough and would a huge detriment to the team because he is so one dimensional and unintelligent.

Tall player for the sake of a tall player.

There are many different ways and different styles of football, he is not **** by any stretch of the imagination BUT he doesn't suit our style of football both in play and ideology.