Jamie Redknapp

[Dhav]

Souey, StevieG, Stevie Mac, Jan and Gary Mac

I'll give you 3 out of those 5. But not Gary Mac. And McManaman was a completely different type of player.

Gary Mac had a greater influence on the team in one season than Redknapp had in 10. And he was 35 at the time. In my book Gary Mac is a greater Liverpool legend than Redknapp, despite the fact he probably didnt play as many as 50 games for us.

[alunevans]

I know I'm risking the wrath of a lot of fans but am I alone in thinking Redknapp was one of the most ovrrated players of recent times. I agree with everything above totally

hugely overrated yes. we won the treble without him so he can't have been that impacting. could hit a great shot two inches above the bar though.

[alunevans]

you fancy him too Sarah?

[DannyMan2006]

Putting aside Redknapps 'expert' and 'interesting' views on anything and everything we can all surely agree on one thing - he was an average central midfielder not in the same class as a Souey, StevieG, Stevie Mac, Jan and Gary Mac - can we agree on this?

Redknapp was a very good midfielder, Souness and Gerrard were World Class, Jan was top quality and Gary Mac was the right player at the right time.

All of the above barring Redders and StevieG were surrounded by complimentary players who were of a high standard. I doubt Molby would have done much better in the kick and rush premiership that Redders played in, especially when he had no one to do the tackling or running for him.

Unfair post in otherwords. No one said he was an LFC legend or a World Class player, just that he was a very good one, and barring injuries could have been even better.

And he was also a top, top pro, and a great example to kids, which is why he was probably captain.

[Red_hot]

you fancy him too Sarah?

No he's too much of a pretty boy for me but he does wear nice shirt and tie combos.

[Neil Young]

No he's too much of a pretty boy for me but he does wear nice shirt and tie combos.

You prefer ugs, eh?

[Red_hot]

You prefer ugs, eh?

Not at all. Just more rugged looking men that don't look like they'd spend more time in the bathroom than me! I like a man to be a man.

[Neil Young]

Not at all. Just more rugged looking men that don't look like they'd spend more time in the bathroom than me! I like a man to be a man.

Ah, thanks for the clarification. The Glove can rest easy.

[Red_hot]

Ah, thanks for the clarification. The Glove can rest easy.

I was with a gay on Friday night. He didn't fancy Sean Bean!!! He did however share my love* for David Tennant.






















*lust

[Neil Young]

I was with a gay on Friday night. He didn't fancy Sean Bean!!! He did however share my love* for David Tennant.

*lust

Helios_Creed alertHelios_Creed alertHelios_Creed alertHelios_Creed alert

I met some of Sean Bean's drinking buddies recently. If you make it worth my while, I could tell you which Working Man's Club he visits regularly.

[Mumsafan]

I was with a gay on Friday night. He didn't fancy Sean Bean!!! He did however share my love* for David Tennant.






















*lust

David Tennant is quite effeminate I think.

[Red_hot]

Helios_Creed alertHelios_Creed alertHelios_Creed alertHelios_Creed alert

I met some of Sean Bean's drinking buddies recently. If you make it worth my while, I could tell you which Working Man's Club he visits regularly.

[Neil Young]

Yes. Really.

[Shaggy]

I was with a gay on Friday night. He didn't fancy Sean Bean!!! He did however share my love* for David Tennant.





















*lust

My missus fancies the boy Tennant too.

[Charlie_B]

The Tennant is fit.