Carson Or Reina?

[bobbyfallon]

Casillas, Buffon, Cech,

Dunno anyone else

in your opinion of course

[PTP]

Casillas, Buffon, Cech,

Dunno anyone else

slightly off topic but has anyone been watching the spanish footie recently - casillas has been ****ing unreal

[dww]

I don't rate Cech as better than Reina, maybe same level, not better

I think Cech has declined in the last season or so. Before that he was genuinely awesome the first keeper since Schmeichel in the PL that you could see strikers put off by him merely because it was him. At present I think you analysis is spot on - the thing is though that bhoth are young and either could improve.

[Joe King]

slightly off topic but has anyone been watching the spanish footie recently - casillas has been ****ing unreal

Casillas has been one of Reals unsung heroes for years. He was one of the reasons why they won the title last season.

[Morph]

I think Cech has declined in the last season or so. Before that he was genuinely awesome the first keeper since Schmeichel in the PL that you could see strikers put off by him merely because it was him. At present I think you analysis is spot on - the thing is though that bhoth are young and either could improve.

yeah he does seem to have had a dowturn since that head injury, pity we've not been able to capitalise on chelseas indifferent season

[PTP]

Casillas has been one of Reals unsung heroes for years. He was one of the reasons why they won the title last season.

i have always thought he was good - put his form for the last 6 games or so has been magnificent

[desertscouser]

I reckon Carson is as good if not better then Reina. I cant remember the last time Reina made a decent stop. Alot of the goals conceded have done so without a decent effort at stopping then. His penalty saving skills cant be questioned but as for in normal play more questions need to be asked, he's getting off way to easy.

I respect people's opinions but this is just outrageous. Alongside Clemence Reina is our best ever keeper. I wouldn't touch Carson with a barge pole. He's a huge liability and isn't fit to lace Reina's boots.

[tomasjj]

I reckon Carson is as good if not better then Reina. I cant remember the last time Reina made a decent stop. Alot of the goals conceded have done so without a decent effort at stopping then. His penalty saving skills cant be questioned but as for in normal play more questions need to be asked, he's getting off way to easy.

Carson is ****e - I think you're having a laugh!

For the only time in history so far, I agree 100% with carheex.

[MrMichael]

A quailty goalkeeper doesn't have to pull of spectacular saves that often.

I struggle to think of any goals we've conceded this season you can say Reina should have got to. He's about the only player in the team this season to be pretty much above criticism imo.

[IrishCop]

If anything it's woke a few people up this morn!!!!!

[Morph]

Carson is ****e - I think you're having a laugh!

Are you serious?? Carson is ****e compared to Pepe, who has consistently been one of the very best in the world since he joined us.

Is this a wind up?

It's a bad day but not that bad, get the blinkers off, Reina is KING (or is that queen?)

The reason Pepe isn't exposed enough to have to make eye-catching saves is due to two reasons, one that we have a good defence and secondly that he's so quick off his line that the opposition struggle to get clear cut chances. He's very good at punching under pressure and catching when not and his distribution is great.

Instead of saying you don't remember him making good saves ask yourself has he let any goals in that he really should have saved? That's the litmus test as far as keepers go.

lot more to a goalies game than just making saves.

IF you are in the right position you don't need to dive

Reina is briliant as being the 5th defender/sweeper. Go to a game and watch him sometime

**** i'm defending a liverpool player what's wrong with me? Nevermind ffs carson is **** compared to reina and if we can get the 8 million on top of the 2 for carson we've done very well. There are other areas of the pitch that need looking at, goalkeeper most certainly isn't one of 'em.

well unfortunately you're wrong, i know opinions can't be wrong, but yours is

we haven't let better keepers leave the club at all, and he's the best keeper we've had since grobbelar and probably at this stage is a better all round keeper.

i'd find it hard to blame any of our conceeded goals this season on him, I reckon you go and have a look at the facts before making such claims

Reina is the best goalie i've seen at Anfield in a long long time if not all the times i;ve been going and thats since the late 70's

next time your at a match watch him, his speed of the line and anticipation is 2nd to none

this has to be a wind up

pepe reina is in the top 5 keepers in the world...

anyone care to name 5 better than him??

personally i think he is class and hope he says as no1 for at least 5-8 years

How you can post this without having watched either keeper in action is beyond me.

At least I presume you havent watched either in action

Reina is one of the best keepers in the premiership (only Cech is clear better than him) & will only get better

I'd be absolutely stunned if there's even one other person, out of the 4,500 members of this forum, and has ever watched one single game of both Carson's and Pepe's, shares IrishCop's view.

Pepe is a top keeper, one of the top two in the league IMO. Sadly I fear there may be a possibility that he'll leave when Rafa goes.

Bloody hell, we might have some problems on and off the pitch at our great club but our first choice goalkeeper certainly isn't one of them. Crazy to suggest he's only average

I respect people's opinions but this is just outrageous. Alongside Clemence Reina is our best ever keeper. I wouldn't touch Carson with a barge pole. He's a huge liability and isn't fit to lace Reina's boots.

I think you're onto a loser here mate

[Imy]

A quailty goalkeeper doesn't have to pull of spectacular saves that often.

I struggle to think of any goals we've conceded this season you can say Reina should have got to. He's about the only player in the team this season to be pretty much above criticism imo.

Agree on the whole, he should have done better vs the Arsenal (if i remember correctly)

[lfc1394]

....and kuyt is better than crouch

[IrishCop]

Just put it out there to get a tread underway, Been awake since 6 need something to kick start the day!

[carheex]

For the only time in history so far, I agree 100% with carheex.

In that case I'm changing my mind!