Man U v Liverpool - Man for man

[Diego]

Honestly?

VDS over Reina - ok i'll give you that
Neville over Finnan - aswell
Rio over Carra - never
Vidic over Hyppia - agger over vidic any time
Evra over Riise - never in a million years
Ronaldo over Gerrard - not sure, but ronaldo over any other rm
Scholes over Alonso - not on a good day
Carrick over Sissoko - not a chance
Giggs over Gonzalez- yes
Saha over Crouch - yes
Rooney over Kuyt - obvious

Sorry fellas and i could do the same with Chelski too

[Mumsafan]

Okay now I don't follow Man U very much so I can't say this is their prefered 11 at the moment, I know Scholes should be in there somewhere, but not sure where he fits, probably more in a 4-3-3 or something. But if for arguments sake we went head to head with what looks like both starting 11's

---------------Reina--------------
---Finnan--Carra--Hyypia--Riise---
-Gerrard-Sissoko-Alonso-whoever-
-----------Kuyt--Bellamy---------

---------Rooney--Saha--------------
-Giggs--Fletcher--Carrick--Ronaldo---
---Evra--Brown--Ferdinand--Neville---
----------Van Der Sar----------------

Who would you take over our own players like for like in position
I'd probably only take Rooney and Giggs, instead of Bellamy and whoever we choose deploy left at the time. Of course Rooney's not on form but I'm sure he'll find it (most likely against us).

Basically, I'm trying to decide if we have the better starting 11 regardless of form.

What's everyone else's thoughts on this?

My thoughts are I couldn't give a **** about them or anyone else. We should just get our own house in order

[Morph]

My thoughts are I couldn't give a **** about them or anyone else. We should just get our own house in order

Like I said that's someone dredging up an old thread from about 3 weeks ago.