Dear Guest
Thank you for visiting! est189 will soon be closing its doors (do forums have doors?) please visit the following thread - (to wail & cry perhaps?)
https://www.est1892.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?p=4002484#post4002484
Thanjk you.
Paul.S
Whenever Newcastle pinned their hopes on a past hero like Keegan, Robson or Shearer, I felt sorry for them. I thought they were living in the past, and inevitably, those managers were doomed from the outset. They were legends, but life could never match up to the rose tinted memories each man was associated with.
I can't quite shake the feeling that if we went with King Kenny, we'd be going down the same route. He is a living legend. He played a blinder in the first ever Liverpool match I went to, but in the current circumstances, he simply can't repeat his 80s success now.
Whenever Newcastle pinned their hopes on a past hero like Keegan, Robson or Shearer, I felt sorry for them. I thought they were living in the past, and inevitably, those managers were doomed from the outset. They were legends, but life could never match up to the rose tinted memories each man was associated with.
I can't quite shake the feeling that if we went with King Kenny, we'd be going down the same route. He is a living legend. He played a blinder in the first ever Liverpool match I went to, but in the current circumstances, he simply can't repeat his 80s success now.
I agree with this. There's no evidence to back this up but it's just a gut feeling.
Whenever Newcastle pinned their hopes on a past hero like Keegan, Robson or Shearer, I felt sorry for them. I thought they were living in the past, and inevitably, those managers were doomed from the outset. They were legends, but life could never match up to the rose tinted memories each man was associated with.
I can't quite shake the feeling that if we went with King Kenny, we'd be going down the same route. He is a living legend. He played a blinder in the first ever Liverpool match I went to, but in the current circumstances, he simply can't repeat his 80s success now.
There is no way that Robson or Kenny (or Keegan for that matter) were failures at Newcastle. There performances well exceeded the realistic ambitions that The Toon should have had. Their only failings are as a consequence of the fact that the clubs fans (waves to neighbours) are all totally retarded. A bunch of over ambitious, unrealistic simpletons for a want of a better comparison.
It baffles me to hear people say he didn't do well there as I think he did a more than acceptable job (3rd in the league and agonisingly close to the FA Cup). Incodently after that cup loss their fans went on a rampage and smashed up the town. ****wits!
A lot of people run a race to see who is fastest. I run to see who has the most guts, who can punish himself into exhausting pace, and then at the end, punish himself even more.
He is used to managing in a way that is different to nowadays.
Full backs are different, midfielders have more to do, strikers play diffrerently - not saying he would struggle but it wouldnt surprise me if he took some time to get started.
under kenny we had some decent attacking fullbacks so i dont think that the problem. in terms of formations you need to realise that we have just let go of a manager who played a defensive and highly inflexible system which made us look boring and unimaginative.
i dont think formations will stump kenny but where i think the biggest change has come over the past 20 years is in the micro management of players with serious advances in nutrition, the medical treatment (20 years ago any player being treated in serbia with horse placenta would have told you to **** off) the stats analysis of games ie prozone etc, and in general the science of football.
its whether a manager from the last era can adapt to these sorts of changes in the modern game. if you add to that the headache of players wages, egos and even academy players on decent money then it might be a step too far.
[B]Sir Isaac Newton knew the universal law of karma - any action has its equal and opposite reaction.[B]
There is no way that Robson or Kenny (or Keegan for that matter) were failures at Newcastle. There performances well exceeded the realistic ambitions that The Toon should have had. Their only failings are as a consequence of the fact that the clubs fans (waves to neighbours) are all totally retarded. A bunch of over ambitious, unrealistic simpletons for a want of a better comparison.
It baffles me to hear people say he didn't do well there as I think he did a more than acceptable job (3rd in the league and agonisingly close to the FA Cup). Incodently after that cup loss their fans went on a rampage and smashed up the town. ****wits!
They were failures because their ambitions were never matched, unrealistic or not. Let's also not forget the fact that they were throwing money around buying players such as Shearer, Asprilla etc ...
Newcastle are a big club, whether you like it or not. They have a very loyal fan base. Why would it be unrealistic for them to wish for a successful team if they have the right financial backing?
What failed them is to hold on to past glories, a bit like Liverpool FC.
If Dalglish has moved with the times then I can think of no better man to lead Liverpool. But It is impossible to know if he has moved on. If he went back to his training methods and team bonding sessions of the 80's and 90's it would be a huge disaster waiting to happen.
Having said that, watching how many touches we sometimes need before giving a pass makes me long for training sessions of constant two-touch five a sides every day like they used to.
I know that's a bit naive, but maybe we've lost something somewhere too.
Klopp on LFC vs MUFC (March 9th 2016) - "This is why I love football. This is why we watched it when we were young. I can still not have enough of it."
Always, keep your face to the sun, and shadows will fall behind you.
I think a lot would depend on how much Kenny was willing to delegate and which coaches he decided to work with. O'Neill for example by repute does almost no training ground work. Kenny has been around the club and presumably has a decent relationship with Sammy Lee who has been involved in the day to day training under Rafa.
"The man who never alters his opinion is like standing water, and breeds reptiles of the mind."
-- William Blake
I think a lot would depend on how much Kenny was willing to delegate and which coaches he decided to work with. O'Neill for example by repute does almost no training ground work. Kenny has been around the club and presumably has a decent relationship with Sammy Lee who has been involved in the day to day training under Rafa.
Sammy Lee will be moved on or given an different job.
It does sound as though people think he might have been cryogenicaly frozen since 1992.
Self drive you mickey mouse piece of ****tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt tttttttttttttt!!!
Klopp on LFC vs MUFC (March 9th 2016) - "This is why I love football. This is why we watched it when we were young. I can still not have enough of it."
Always, keep your face to the sun, and shadows will fall behind you.
In my opinion the best person to assess the capabilities of Kenny is the man himself. If he felt he was still capable of managing in the modern game I am sure with the club hanging over the precipice, as it is, he would put himself forward. It is obvious that he feels there are people more capable out there. If all possibilities are exhausted and he does still feel like he can take the club forward, then I am sure he would rise to the challenge.
The concern I have is that I believe in the mantra ' never go back '. Look at Keegan. When he went back to Newcastle, he looked completely out of his depth. I now we are talking about a different personality to Kenny but Keegan had only been out of the game for four or five years at that time.
I think David moyes would be a great candidate, he's one of the new breed of Managers and is one of the few that have had proven success.
I think what liverpool need more than anything is a consistent approach to rebuilding. Rafa Benitez got fired because despite winning the Champs league and an FA CUP and getting us to another final and quite some semis, he only ever challenged for the league realistically once and that was in a very poor year for the likes of Arsenal and Chelsea. I would rather that the new manager made us challenge for the title year in year out and win it at least once that win the champs league once or even twice after qualifying for it in fourth place.
Although we won the champions league in 2005, it still grates with me that we only finished 5th in our own league. i know his first comments after winning the Champs league was we need to change the team and he was backed, but at the end of the day he never challenged as well as he did with Gerard Houlliers team.
Jacques Brel is alive and well and playing at Anfield
I think David moyes would be a great candidate, he's one of the new breed of Managers and is one of the few that have had proven success.
I think what liverpool need more than anything is a consistent approach to rebuilding. Rafa Benitez got fired because despite winning the Champs league and an FA CUP and getting us to another final and quite some semis, he only ever challenged for the league realistically once and that was in a very poor year for the likes of Arsenal and Chelsea. I would rather that the new manager made us challenge for the title year in year out and win it at least once that win the champs league once or even twice after qualifying for it in fourth place.
Although we won the champions league in 2005, it still grates with me that we only finished 5th in our own league. i know his first comments after winning the Champs league was we need to change the team and he was backed, but at the end of the day he never challenged as well as he did with Gerard Houlliers team.
What about the team that finished 2nd in the league that wasn't Houllier's team
The only gracious way to accept an insult is to ignore it; if you can't ignore it, top it; if you can't top it, laugh at it; if you can't laugh at it, it's probably deserved.
Comment