Would you bring in a manager on a temporary basis until the summer?

[elrichio86]

I voted to keep him till the summer

I just think it would take 5 - 10 games for the caretaker to undo Roys work, by which point we would be 10 points or so behind where Roy would have managed to get us anyway. Roys had 6 months to get his plans in place - do we write off another month or so of the season whilst a caretaker gets sorted (and all the upheaval associated with that)?

I see it as a case of Roy would give us 5 months of average / mediocre form, whereas a caretaker would give us 2 months of crap form followed by 3 months of good / average form. I think we would end up with marginally more points from Roy than a caretaker.

And thats assuming the caretaker was a success - there's no guarantees unfortunately.

[Tee]

Get rid of Roy NOW, get Kenny in for the rest of the season. If he does a good job and wants to stay on then problem solved, if not go get a proper Manager in the Summer.

[saj]

Get rid of Roy NOW, get Kenny in for the rest of the season. If he does a good job and wants to stay on then problem solved, if not go get a proper Manager in the Summer.

[Vermilion]

Get rid of Roy NOW, get Kenny in for the rest of the season. If he does a good job and wants to stay on then problem solved, if not go get a proper Manager in the Summer.

Is the right answer.

We've seen no feel good factor at all in replacing Rafa, and that's because i believe it was a very small minority of players who wanted him gone, we could just have the opposite reaction were we to sack the Bodger, and achieve that feel good factor we need.

[BG1973]

Don't really see any advantage in getting rid now. Wait until the summer where the market for players and managers will be much better. And i don't really want Kenny back as an interim because it won't really gain anything and I want to remember him at the very top. Not mid table battles.

That's the sensible option in my opinion.

[RedReet]

Sack Hodgson.

Dalglish, Lee, Thommo, Barnes, Staunton, Ablett, Neal,

I would actually back any of these to do better and the latter 4 are truly **** to.

KK and Thompson as assistant. I don’t blame Sammy for the results since he’s returned to the club, but unfortunately the stats don’t favour him.

[G]

Wrong thread

[Rigadon]

Get rid. Now!

Bring in Dalglish and Phil Thompson.

[Craig_H]

If it meant sacking Hodgson, i'd even happily bring in Bender and Perkins.

[Assassin]

If it meant sacking Hodgson, i'd even happily bring in Bender and Perkins.

[RichC]

The dynamic duo at the helm - unstopable I tell ya, unstopable!

[little dave hedgehog]

but sausage is a step too far.

[Exiled_red]

I don't think that option 2 is a viable option no manager is 100% sure to be a success, otherwise you wouldn't need to sack a manager in the first place.

I voted option one because of this and we need rid of Hodgson.

[Mostar]

Get rid of Roy NOW, get Kenny in for the rest of the season. If he does a good job and wants to stay on then problem solved, if not go get a proper Manager in the Summer.

No brainer.

[paulg]

This is typical, Hughton gets sacked for doing a good job.

Allardyce gets sacked and, well I'm still laughing.

Roy is dragging us lower and lower and it's pretty obvious he's going nowhere.

Football is nuts.