Luis Suárez

[The_weatherman]

Its all about the age of who is giving the answer though isnt it? If asked Id say Barnes was our best ever player. Ive never seen anyone use the ball better than him in a Red shirt.

But you ask someone 10 years older than me they might say Dalglish.

I think a lot of kids growing up now a days will have Suarez as pretty high on their list. Just like people 10 years younger than me will say Gerrard for his CL and FA cup final wins.

So I take the view that Daglish/Barnes/Gerrard are our best ever players. Impossible to separate. Suarez is in that group behind.

I agree, in the premiership era, just about when I started follow this bloody thing, I think I'd class it as Gerrard - Suarez - Torres - Fowler - Hyypia. But that's without putting a whole lot of thought into it.

[The Birdman]

Suarez has played consistantly well for us for 1 season.
Thats it, 1 season.

On another point for much of 87-90 John Barnes was unplayable. He was like Ronaldo was for Man U only with the goals on **** pitches and waist high tackles.

[Alex]

The question isnt who is consistently the best though is it? Its more about ability I thought. As I said, Suarez is up there. Just nothing like Barnes or Gerrard in there day from what I watched.

Also, Gerrard is the best player I have ever seen play live. He was totally unplayable in 2007-2009.

[Yozza]

Its all about the age of who is giving the answer though isnt it? If asked Id say Barnes was our best ever player. Ive never seen anyone use the ball better than him in a Red shirt.

But you ask someone 10 years older than me they might say Dalglish.

I think a lot of kids growing up now a days will have Suarez as pretty high on their list. Just like people 10 years younger than me will say Gerrard for his CL and FA cup final wins.

So I take the view that Daglish/Barnes/Gerrard are our best ever players. Impossible to separate. Suarez is in that group behind.

[Arn]

The question isnt who is consistently the best though is it? Its more about ability I thought. As I said, Suarez is up there. Just nothing like Barnes or Gerrard in there day from what I watched.

Also, Gerrard is the best player I have ever seen play live. He was totally unplayable in 2007-2009.

Suarez been totally unplayable this season and that with probably our worst midfield since the stoneage behind him.

What he done this season is more than fantastic or excellent, it is much better than that.

Many fans says that Gerrard carried the team many years but he had some fantastic players behind him like Xabi and Masch. We also had Kuyt, probably the most hard working player out there. Gerrard got a lot of space because of that. He didn't had to do a lot of work himself like Suarez must do this season.

Suarez is simply the best player in the league right now and that with some distance. Bale or RvP isn't even close.

Not even Ronaldo at his best at United was as good as Suarez is now.

IMO Suarez season is the best ever by any player in a long time.

[dom9]

Well this is getting heated.

[Alex]

Suarez been totally unplayable this season and that with probably our worst midfield since the stoneage behind him.

What he done this season is more than fantastic or excellent, it is much better than that.

Many fans says that Gerrard carried the team many years but he had some fantastic players behind him like Xabi and Masch. We also had Kuyt, probably the most hard working player out there. Gerrard got a lot of space because of that. He didn't had to do a lot of work himself like Suarez must do this season.

Suarez is simply the best player in the league right now and that with some distance. Bale or RvP isn't even close.

Not even Ronaldo at his best at United was as good as Suarez is now.

IMO Suarez season is the best ever by any player in a long time.

Think you are letting your dislike of Gerrard get in the way here mate. You could say the exact same thing for Messi. Xavi, Ineista, Villa, Alves and Busquets all do the work for him. Messi essentially moves for about 10 minutes a game. Those 10 minutes are pure magic. But it doesnt detract from him that the others do the hard work.

Gerrard was the best player in a ****ing amazing Midfield at the time. Thats something. Alonso, Masch and Gerrard was a 3 I cant say enough good things about.

[cream]

Suarez been totally unplayable this season and that with probably our worst midfield since the stoneage behind him.

What he done this season is more than fantastic or excellent, it is much better than that.

Many fans says that Gerrard carried the team many years but he had some fantastic players behind him like Xabi and Masch. We also had Kuyt, probably the most hard working player out there. Gerrard got a lot of space because of that. He didn't had to do a lot of work himself like Suarez must do this season.

Suarez is simply the best player in the league right now and that with some distance. Bale or RvP isn't even close.

Not even Ronaldo at his best at United was as good as Suarez is now.

IMO Suarez season is the best ever by any player in a long time.

Nah, both Gerrard and Ronaldo were better players than Suarez.

[spider-neil]

The best Liverpool players ever IMO-
1. Dalglish
2. Gerrard
3. Rush
4. Suárez
5. Souness

I don't rate Suarez as good as Barnes.

[fah-q]

The best Liverpool players ever IMO-
1. Dalglish
2. Gerrard
3. Rush
4. Suárez
5. Souness

No Barnes????

[Lecter]

Its all about the age of who is giving the answer though isnt it? If asked Id say Barnes was our best ever player. Ive never seen anyone use the ball better than him in a Red shirt.

But you ask someone 10 years older than me they might say Dalglish.

I think a lot of kids growing up now a days will have Suarez as pretty high on their list. Just like people 10 years younger than me will say Gerrard for his CL and FA cup final wins.

So I take the view that Daglish/Barnes/Gerrard are our best ever players. Impossible to separate. Suarez is in that group behind.

Dalglish, Gerrard, Barnes would be my top 3 (in that order)

The thing is when you look at the list of all time players it makes you weep. We've had some incredible players over the years

In fact I'd quite happily take some of the players from the second or third tier down from the trinity mentioned above

[Darkon]

Suarez needs to play for us for several seasons before being compared to Barnes/Dalglish/Gerrard etc. He might do a Torres, and although a very good player for us for 2 season, it's hardly comparable to any of the greats.

He has the ability, determination and drive to be one of the best players in a red shirt, but he needs to prove it over a longer period of time with some consistency to it.

[Alex]

Dalglish, Gerrard, Barnes would be my top 3 (in that order)

The thing is when you look at the list of all time players it makes you weep. We've had some incredible players over the years

In fact I'd quite happily take some of the players from the second or third tier down from the trinity mentioned above

Yep, just think of the players in the Prem era alone who are all time greats.

Fowler, Owen, Hyypia, Hamman, Carragher, Alonso, Torres, Reina and Biscan.

Its amazing how many legends we have had play for us.

[Lecter]

Yep, just think of the players in the Prem era alone who are all time greats.

Fowler, Owen, Hyypia, Hamman, Carragher, Alonso, Torres, Reina and Biscan.

Its amazing how many legends we have had play for us.

You look at the Premier League era players you've listed and I'm none to sure any of them would have got into the team of the late 70's & 80's and yet they are absoutely world class players in some cases

And flmao at Biscan

[Tee]

My personal top 5:

1. Gerrard
2. Rush
3. Barnes
4. Torres
5. Dalglish

It is a personal thing and in my lifetime watching Liverpool I would say those players have made the biggest impact on me, in that order obviously.

We are so lucky we have had dozens of absolutely brilliant players over the years, so any top 5 is going to be tough to pick!