Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

New manager thread

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Of course trophies are nice but I wouldn't expect even City to win two trophies. One is enough.

    4th place is priority. Trophies are nice.
    The times they are a changin'.

    Comment


      Originally posted by broman View Post
      Yeah, Portsmouth definitely wouldn't want to trade places with Arsenal right now.

      Oh, wait.
      I was not talking about trading places ... I was talking about experiences that you remember until the end of your life ... Exactly what is the point of Arsenal at the moment? To generate money for their owners? To entertain their audience with beautiful football? Ultimately, it is all about what you win ... No-one remembers how many times you have participated in the competition, unless you win it ...

      Comment


        Originally posted by Macedonian_Red View Post
        I was not talking about trading places ... I was talking about experiences that you remember until the end of your life ... Exactly what is the point of Arsenal at the moment? To generate money for their owners? To entertain their audience with beautiful football? Ultimately, it is all about what you win ... No-one remembers how many times you have participated in the competition, unless you win it ...
        You could argue Wenger's gone stagnant. The game is passing him by.

        Comment


          Originally posted by Kronenburg1892 View Post
          Almost all against packed defences. That's been the problem. I really have struggled to name Kenny's best 11 all season. And struggled even harder to work out what he has up his sleave to change a game when plan A isn't working.

          I'm sorry, but we have to be honest, there's some significant developments in coaching in the last 5 years, and I honestly doubt Kenny is/was on top of all the new theories coming out of the continents experience. You have to keep ontop of all of this to have a competitive edge. I think Kenny's folly was to go down a sabremetrics style that Comolloi bought in. No plan B.

          To repeat, both Martinez and Rodgers both took 4 points off us. Both have similar philosophies, with way smaller budgets or win to wage ratios. That has to lead you to the conclusion that they had the fresher ideas. How ever hard that is to swallow.

          Kenny has dealt with it like the man we all know him to be.
          Promise you mate, we never once went down that route, at least not past a primary school version of it.
          www.Liverpoolbaymlt.org

          www.twitter.com/lbmlt

          www.Facebook.com/liverpoolbaymarinelifetrust

          Comment


            Originally posted by Macedonian_Red View Post
            Challenge for what? We will still be in the Europa League, at least 10 points from the CL places ... It seems that you still don't understand the implications of the FSG's decision to sack Kenny ... No new LFC manager will survive the failure to qualify for the CL next season, especially since Rafa is available at the moment and willing to take the job ... The precedent has already been set, and there is no turning back ...
            Rubbish; you are reducing their decision making to what suits your own argument and calling it a precedent based on that. I doubt our owners are as simple and unthinking as this would have us believe.

            Whether you feel Kenny should have been sacked or not, it's right that particularly in the early years of a manager's charge their performance should be assessed to a greater extent on their overarching vision for the club and what signs there are it is starting to take root. Without any intimate knowledge of those plans that is very difficult to analyse and those within the club are far better placed to comment on it, lack of football experience notwithstanding. I'm not sure Kenny's long term strategy was all that clear from outside, which could be a sign that is was weak or poorly executed. Perhaps if that hadn't been the case he may still be here, even with a similarly disappointing season.

            Comolli also being gone suggests the owners now have a better idea of what direction they want the club to take. The little we know about the current recruitment drive lends weight to that theory, with the club looking to put a set of people with a cohesive vision in place rather than a big name in complete control. Whether that works or not is another matter, but it's clearly something with some genuine thought and strategy behind it rather than the brainless "no CL = fail + fire + hire" equation you've put together.
            Like blood on iron

            Comment


              Originally posted by Mattshark View Post
              Promise you mate, we never once went down that route, at least not past a primary school version of it.
              I'm not so sure. Unless you can convince me otherwise. Henderson had stats written all over his performance and inclusion last year.

              Comment


                Originally posted by Kronenburg1892 View Post
                You could argue Wenger's gone stagnant. The game is passing him by.
                But as you can see, Arsenal owners would never sack him, as long as he is getting them their CL money ... They also have no problem selling a star player every summer, as long as they are getting their CL money ... In reality, Arsenal are the ugly face of the modern day football ... A money making machine for their owners, with no prospect of winning the Champions League or the Premier League in the near future ...

                Comment


                  Originally posted by NigelLG View Post
                  I disagree. Winning trophies increases our profile and brings revenue in terms of worldwide appeal, merchandise etc. LFC don't play for 4th. We play to win.
                  Yes, and we play to win the biggest trophies most of all, to reach the pinnacle.

                  Winning the league cup is clearly good and represents an achievement of itself, but if we underperform significantly in the league we slip away from realising those much more important goals. So whilst the history books may show this season as more successful than if we'd finished 4th and won no cups, the point is we're rightly thinking about our future success and prospects as well. You could still argue whilst acknowledging this that Kenny was the man to take us forward, but I think it's very naive to paint the season in the light you do in terms of how good it was for the club.
                  Like blood on iron

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by Mattshark View Post
                    Promise you mate, we never once went down that route, at least not past a primary school version of it.
                    Matt you keep saying this but how do you know? Relying on a simplistic version of it could very well be a reason why one or both were sacked rather than evidence it wasn't being used.
                    Like blood on iron

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by Macedonian_Red View Post
                      I was not talking about trading places ... I was talking about experiences that you remember until the end of your life ... Exactly what is the point of Arsenal at the moment? To generate money for their owners? To entertain their audience with beautiful football? Ultimately, it is all about what you win ... No-one remembers how many times you have participated in the competition, unless you win it ...
                      Sure you weren't. Anyway, the "point" of qualifying for the CL (and by extension Arsenal, in your example) is actually quite simple. CL qualification -> more money, higher profile -> better players -> chance to challenge for #19 and #6. Winning domestic cups is nice and all, but they do ****-all for those two goals and for us as a club. Prioritize cups and soon enough you'll have fallen far enough behind that you're not challenging even for those, let alone the ones that matter.

                      How do you think we won those cups, eh? With players. And if we keep failing to qualify for the CL, how much longer do you think those players - Agger, Suarez, Skrtel, Lucas, Reina - are going to stick around? And when they leave, what type of player will we be able to attract?

                      Originally posted by Macedonian_Red View Post
                      But as you can see, Arsenal owners would never sack him, as long as he is getting them their CL money ... They also have no problem selling a star player every summer, as long as they are getting their CL money ... In reality, Arsenal are the ugly face of the modern day football ... A money making machine for their owners, with no prospect of winning the Champions League or the Premier League in the near future ...
                      How does this relate to Liverpool at all? Okay, so Arsenal have poor owners who don't invest in the club. That doesn't change the fact that CL qualification is good for the club.
                      Last edited by Hemingway; 30-05-12, 12:43 AM.

                      Comment


                        Hedgehog, think you need to bring the Craig Meme out
                        The times they are a changin'.

                        Comment


                          Originally posted by Macedonian_Red View Post
                          But as you can see, Arsenal owners would never sack him, as long as he is getting them their CL money ... They also have no problem selling a star player every summer, as long as they are getting their CL money ... In reality, Arsenal are the ugly face of the modern day football ... A money making machine for their owners, with no prospect of winning the Champions League or the Premier League in the near future ...
                          Yes they are. And that is the reality of the league today. If we hadn't have imploded over January or Redknap thinking he'd got the Engerland job, or Drogba missing a penalty, top 4 could have been quite different.

                          The percentage is all to play for.

                          Teams knew how to set up against us last year. That is the failing of Kenny imo, as will be against anyone else.

                          Comment


                            Originally posted by Gibbo9 View Post
                            Hedgehog, think you need to bring the Craig Meme out
                            want to, but i'm on my phone.
                            dave of mutilation

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by little dave hedgehog View Post
                              want to, but i'm on my phone.
                              can you not just put them on hold a minute?
                              _____________________________________

                              Weak willed, Wank or do they have a masterplan?

                              Think we have the answer..Slot!!

                              Comment


                                Trey Nyoni: countdown to stardom- 2 years 1year 0.5 years

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X