Simon Mignolet

[tanner]

I'd rather have Peter Dinklage between the sticks than either of our two.

[meffin]

Surely we have youth keepers who aren't going to be any worse than Mig or Brad?

[Fierce]

career highlights

.....conceded 4 goals in a 6–4 victory one of which was direct from his own goal kick.............

[RedReet]

Surely we have youth keepers who aren't going to be any worse than Mig or Brad?

Nah, they are generally pretty poor. Don't think I've seen Vigoroux play since he signed from Spurs, but none of the rest have ever impressed me.

[BigChief]

Whilst not a huge fan, still think he'd have save both of those yesterday and wouldn't it be nice to see LFC improve a young goalkeeper for once rather than discard them?

I'd happily keep him as an understudy to a more experienced keeper.

Would also have conceded different types of goals. For example, Jones cleared that through ball for Giroud just in time. My heart sank when I saw the ball being played, but hope entered it when I remembered Mig wasn't playing. That was a certain goal had Mig been in.

No point sticking around as an understudy. Fulton can do that.

[Rich]

Five goals conceded from eight shots tells you all you need with our Brad. Terrible goalkeeper.

Mig might not be good enough either but he's a talented shotstopper that has been hung out to dry by Rodgers.

Long term neither should be between the sticks but until we can upgrade Simon then he should be playing.

[BigChief]

Five goals conceded from eight shots tells you all you need with our Brad. Terrible goalkeeper.

Mig might not be good enough either but he's a talented shotstopper that has been hung out to dry by Rodgers.

Long term neither should be between the sticks but until we can upgrade Simon then he should be playing.

Yeah, sadly its the option of having **** on your right shoe or on your left shoe.

[Sarb]

I'd rather have Peter Dinklage between the sticks than either of our two.

[Scratch]

Wonder if we've got another keeper lined up (not that Mexican fella, someone decent) and Mignolet is being put to one side to ensure his value doesn't drop too much or he doesn't get injured?

[Dessy]

Would also have conceded different types of goals. For example, Jones cleared that through ball for Giroud just in time. My heart sank when I saw the ball being played, but hope entered it when I remembered Mig wasn't playing. That was a certain goal had Mig been in.

No point sticking around as an understudy. Fulton can do that.

There every point in sticking around as an understudy if you have the will and desire to succeed in your chosen profession? And there's every point in LFC keeping hold of players who want to improve, fight for their place and realise their potential in a red shirt?

Or perhaps lets just **** em all off and let them develop and excel elsewhere

[Slinky Skills]

Good

If Rodgers has no faith in him then we have to sell him. However, with Skrtel Rodgers has proved that players can work their way back into his good books.

If the answer is Brad Jones then you are definitely asking the wrong question(s). I really hope that Rodgers/the club has a plan for January.

Skrtel's surname is Rodgers?

No wonder he won't drop him, must be his son.

[Kenneth]

Strange how he was suited well enough when we almost won the league.

Either way, he's better than Jones and it's arguable that the decision to drop mignolet has already cost is points.

[dww]

Strange how he was suited well enough when we almost won the league.

Either way, he's better than Jones and it's arguable that the decision to drop mignolet has already cost is points.

Do you really think our defence was good last season? I think most people believed that it and Mignolet were a concern last season and that being amazing in attack hid a multitude of sins. Realistically we aren't going to get back to a position where we have options as good as one or both of Sturridge/Suarez up front for a while so other things need to be better.

[Kenneth]

Before he was dropped he was the reason the defence was chaotic. He wasn't the primary reason. Dropping him for a worse keeper was a stupid choice. The positioning of our back four is awful, that's our biggest weakness, the mignolet situation is little more than a convenient distraction for the manager.

[Muddled]

Five goals conceded from eight shots tells you all you need with our Brad. Terrible goalkeeper.

Mig might not be good enough either but he's a talented shotstopper that has been hung out to dry by Rodgers.

Long term neither should be between the sticks but until we can upgrade Simon then he should be playing.

Spot on.

And we can kiss goodbye to some coin from his inevitable sale.