Reina to leave for Valencia?

[kurtangle01]

Is this not just taken from a lazy arsed Mirror artical which said that Reina's contract was up this year, which was incorrect because they confused Reina's contract expiery with Dudek's.

Do you have a link to said article?

[kurtangle01]

we gotta look at it as a whole package..yes Reina does all them things you mentioned but at the end of the day his job is not only that..we'll see how Carson's situation is gonna develop at CFC. I'd like to retain him instead of keeping Dudek.

Reina is the whole package where as Scott Carson isn't IMHO. I never rated Kirkland and I don't think Carson is much better. I prefer keepers like Reina who are quite quick and agile that can get about their goalmouth. Guys like Carson and Kirkland just simply aren't good at that.

[Mattshark]

Do you have a link to said article?

No but it was on here about a week ago.

[dww]

Reina is the whole package where as Scott Carson isn't IMHO. I never rated Kirkland and I don't think Carson is much better. I prefer keepers like Reina who are quite quick and agile that can get about their goalmouth. Guys like Carson and Kirkland just simply aren't good at that.

I think you are harsh on Carson. I think he needs more experience though. I deally I would want him to play behind a defence that played a similar way to our own and that was not struggling. It is easy to look good in a poor team as a keeper, the real test is to be able to pull of the one important save when you have had sod all to do all game.

[kurtangle01]

I think you are harsh on Carson. I think he needs more experience though. I deally I would want him to play behind a defence that played a similar way to our own and that was not struggling. It is easy to look good in a poor team as a keeper, the real test is to be able to pull of the one important save when you have had sod all to do all game.

I don't think I'm being to harsh to be honest. I'm not slating the guy I just don't think that he has got the required ability to play at the top level. He will do well for a lesser side but for us I don't ever see him being anything more than 2nd choice. Reina is by far the better keeper and we shouldn't be considering selling him, if the story is true.

[UpTheMiddle]

you see that is where i disagree wid ya mate, i think Carson is better than Reina..when he played that game against Juve at Anfield he was immense..he does not fumble the ball as much as Reina and he has that physical presence about him that says GK all over..REINA is too small to be a keeper, he does not command his six yard box like keepers should..Arsenals 1st goal was partly his fault..he should have been more aggressive in collecting that low cross from Fabregas.

According to the offie site, he's 6'2".

Shay Given is one of the best keepers in the premiership & he's only about 5'11".

I think Reina's form has improved in the last 5 or 6 matches & I think you're being overly harsh on him blaming him for the first goal. Each of the 3 goals, in my opinion, was the defense' fault (not the goalkeeper).

[dww]

I don't think I'm being to harsh to be honest. I'm not slating the guy I just don't think that he has got the required ability to play at the top level. He will do well for a lesser side but for us I don't ever see him being anything more than 2nd choice. Reina is by far the better keeper and we shouldn't be considering selling him, if the story is true.

I don't think that anyone has seen enough of him to say anything other than that he has not yet developed into a top keeper and that he is a top shot stopper. Keepers take longer than other players to mature and writing of any young keeper of talent who has played much less than a season of first team football seems harsh to me.

[Resu]

It`s on Eurosport.com according to Liverpool.no

[Mumsafan]

Rafa isn't the sort to go backwards

[kurtangle01]

It`s on Eurosport.com according to Liverpool.no

Nothing on eurosport. It does however say that Kuyt is injured...

[kurtangle01]

Rafa isn't the sort to go backwards

[Shaggy]

you see that is where i disagree wid ya mate, i think Carson is better than Reina..when he played that game against Juve at Anfield he was immense..he does not fumble the ball as much as Reina and he has that physical presence about him that says GK all over..REINA is too small to be a keeper, he does not command his six yard box like keepers should..Arsenals 1st goal was partly his fault..he should have been more aggressive in collecting that low cross from Fabregas.

Reina? Too small? Six foot two?

[kurtangle01]

I don't think that anyone has seen enough of him to say anything other than that he has not yet developed into a top keeper and that he is a top shot stopper. Keepers take longer than other players to mature and writing of any young keeper of talent who has played much less than a season of first team football seems harsh to me.

It's not a matter of experience it's a matter of his quality IMHO. Have you seen some of the goals he has conceded this season? There have been some terriblemistakes by the lad, much worse than some of Pepe's, My intention is not to slag the guy off I just feel that i'm making a fair observation based on the lad as a keeper.

[royzared]

Nothing on eurosport. It does however say that Kuyt is injured...

Slight knock,bit of blood on the shin, should be OK for Holland.

[kurtangle01]

Slight knock,bit of blood on the shin, should be OK for Holland.

I don't give two ****s about Holland I'm more concerned the state they will send him back in.