Which Liverpool player has frustrated you most?

[Kenneth]

Le gems.

[rudedog]

It’s got to be Alberto Aquilani, brought in replace Xabi Alonso

[RedReet]

It’s got to be Alberto Aquilani, brought in replace Xabi Alonso

Think we have a winner.

[labourRed]

Watching, for me was Kuyt in recent times anyway. You love to have him in your team and he was by no means on a level with many previously mentioned, but his general play ****ed me off most of the time while watching.

[Venton]

For me it has to be Emil Heskey. He never used his physique. Built like a lion, played like a lamb. That was the difference between him being a great player and a legend

One minute scaring the life out of the Argentinian defence, the next being bullied by Nigel Winterburn. Ivanhoe my arse.

[Norbs]

Controversial - I'll pick a manager (that we all loved). Rafa Benitez. At one time, we had the best team in the league, but he was too rigid/conservative. We should have been league champions c2009.

Good shout but he was dealing with tight owners at the end so I think he was cutting his own nose off

[Norbs]

The Andy Carroll + Stewart Downing combo had me really really excited. Then it failed to deliver anything of worth

[Cormack74]

Le gems.

Mostly I'd agree, but didn't Pongolle score in the CL 2005 run to the final (the Olypiakos game maybe?) and I have vague recollections of Le Tallec playing well v Juve in the QF too.

So they earned a bit of redemption.

But I've had a couple of drinks so might be off beam here.

[Cormack74]

dupe

[Cormack74]

Good shout but he was dealing with tight owners at the end so I think he was cutting his own nose off

[Kenneth]

Mostly I'd agree, but didn't Pongolle score in the CL 2005 run to the final (the Olypiakos game maybe?) and I have vague recollections of Le Tallec playing well v Juve in the QF too.

So they earned a bit of redemption.

But I've had a couple of drinks so might be off beam here.

I can’t recall le Tallec’s general performance vs juve, but he set up Luis Gracie for his wonder volley. They came with a lot of fanfare, mainly by Houllier too be fair, and I believed him for a while.

[Cormack74]

The hype clearly exceeded the reality, but if they contributed to the CL 2005 win, then I'm prepared to cut them slack for the remainder of their time at the club.

[Liverpool]

Lovren

[Venton]

The hype clearly exceeded the reality, but if they contributed to the CL 2005 win, then I'm prepared to cut them slack for the remainder of their time at the club.

From memory they had excelled at an international youth tournament the year before and they were generally coveted but we got them because of Houllier. I'm not sure how good clubs were at integrating young foreign talent back then...

[SB]

The non signing of Anelka & signing El Hadj Diouf instead was a cluster**** of the highest order. Anelka was desperate to stay & play for us & that had me excited at the proposition.