James Milner

[Kenneth]

£3m

[Chrono]

Assuming for a minute that this link was real how much would you be happy to see us spend on him?

£16.37p

[Exiled_red]

£3m

£16.37p

Thanks, but I meant that to the people who actually rated him

[BillobShaisley]

Come on guys get a grip. OK so he's not Aguero or Nani but FFS £3m?!?!?

He's about as much use as Ashley Young and a similar age.

[dww]

Assuming for a minute that this link was real how much would you be happy to see us spend on him?

I'm not sure, and I've been saying for a while that I don't think speculation about fees is particularly helpful. I would however have preferred him to Henderson or any of the other midfielders we have been linked with (possibly except Mata and with the qualification that I haven't seen that much of Henderson).

[Exiled_red]

I'm not sure, and I've been saying for a while that I don't think speculation about fees is particularly helpful. I would however have preferred him to Henderson or any of the other midfielders we have been linked with (possibly except Mata and with the qualification that I haven't seen that much of Henderson).

I can't see City selling him for much less than they paid, so whether he's worth that or not I can't see us offering that much for him.

[DannyMan2006]

I think he's worth £15m in today's market. And he'd be a great fit in our team, works like a cart horse and has good energy and delivery.

[Exiled_red]

I think he's worth £15m in today's market. And he'd be a great fit in our team, works like a cart horse and has good energy and delivery.

I'd say something similar but City paid ~£10m more than that for him so I can't see them letting him go for that kind of loss, (especially to someone who will be a rival for a top 4 spot).

[Lee]

I think he's worth £15m in today's market. And he'd be a great fit in our team, works like a cart horse and has good energy and delivery.

Without meaning to sound derogatory, we have Kuyt who does the same job.

Milner is decent. No more and no less. City would want much more than what he's really worth (IMO).

[DannyMan2006]

Without meaning to sound derogatory, we have Kuyt who does the same job.

Milner is decent. No more and no less. City would want much more than what he's really worth (IMO).

He's more dynamic than Kuyt IMO, but Kuyt is a better finisher, as you'd expect from an ex (current?) striker.

[Mostar]

I think he's worth £15m in today's market. And he'd be a great fit in our team, works like a cart horse and has good energy and delivery.

Imo there is no way City would even remotely entertain any ideas of selling him unless the starting bid is close to 20m mark.

[Redspin]

Come on guys get a grip. OK so he's not Aguero or Nani but FFS £3m?!?!?

He's about as much use as Ashley Young and a similar age.

Thank you. I was struggling to articulate how ****ing crap this bloke is and your last sentence sums him up admirably

[Daniel 7]

Isn't Milner pretty slow?

He's finished at City, and we seem to have a penchant for north eastern and former north eastern players, so why not? And he's Engerlund, so bound to be a fantastic signing.

[Cormack74]

Isn't Milner pretty slow?

Surely not as slow as our Dirk though?

Can't often be the case that a forward/offensive wide midfield player is the slowest person at a club.

Note; I cannot categorically state that I know this to be true since I am relying on a Jamie Carragher interview as my source.

[Cleo]

Please...
This would be a new Kewell or Keane for us - would go mental if we went down that road again