Originally posted by MrMichael
View Post
Not sure Kenny necessarily "built from the back". His only defensive signings were Enrique and Coates, wheras he spent c. £100m on offensive players. That most of them were **** and couldn't score isn't massively the point. And besides, I don't think the argument that what several managers who were sacked did should be done by the next one too necessarily is very logical.
ManU are the most offensively set up team in this league. And they're running away with it. There is no right and wrong way to do this, when Rodgers came in we had a major problem in attack. which he has made serious inroads into sorting. With 12 games left of this season we've already scored more goals than we did all last season. When you consider we only had one striker for half the season that isn't bad going, and indicates the squad is not as unsuited to what they're being asked to do as you say.
Sure we're conceding more too, but when you look at it on paper, are most of our defenders actually unsuited to this style of play? Johnson's been one of our best this year and is very comfortable in attack. Enrique is definitely better going forward. And you'd think Agger would be quite suited to possession based offensive play too.
I dunno, it just seems a bit simplistic to assume we should have "built from the back". Likely if we did, like the previous managers apparently did, we wouldn't be any higher in the league. We weren't under them in the last 3 years. If anything what's hurt us defensively this year has been the lack of an outstanding defensive mid (and maybe overall midfield shape), Lucas being injured then easing back in, Allen lacking form or ability in that role etc.
We were never going to sort everything out in one season, no matter who was in charge and what philosophy they approached the game with. This season has not been perfect, far from it, but it also hasn't been a disaster and there is plenty of reason to be relatively optimistic about the future if we can gain a bit more solidity defensively.
ManU are the most offensively set up team in this league. And they're running away with it. There is no right and wrong way to do this, when Rodgers came in we had a major problem in attack. which he has made serious inroads into sorting. With 12 games left of this season we've already scored more goals than we did all last season. When you consider we only had one striker for half the season that isn't bad going, and indicates the squad is not as unsuited to what they're being asked to do as you say.
Sure we're conceding more too, but when you look at it on paper, are most of our defenders actually unsuited to this style of play? Johnson's been one of our best this year and is very comfortable in attack. Enrique is definitely better going forward. And you'd think Agger would be quite suited to possession based offensive play too.
I dunno, it just seems a bit simplistic to assume we should have "built from the back". Likely if we did, like the previous managers apparently did, we wouldn't be any higher in the league. We weren't under them in the last 3 years. If anything what's hurt us defensively this year has been the lack of an outstanding defensive mid (and maybe overall midfield shape), Lucas being injured then easing back in, Allen lacking form or ability in that role etc.
We were never going to sort everything out in one season, no matter who was in charge and what philosophy they approached the game with. This season has not been perfect, far from it, but it also hasn't been a disaster and there is plenty of reason to be relatively optimistic about the future if we can gain a bit more solidity defensively.
Comment