Andy Carroll - Best Striker in the World

[Rich]

End of has been called.

The laws of the internet state that no further discussion is of any merit or validity.

Damn right. People should listen to me more often.

[meffin]

Didn't big Andy elbow him earlier in the game though? From watching MOTD, i seem to remember there was an earlier incident that he should have been sent off for..?

[Maxiedge]

End of has been called.

The laws of the internet state that any further discussion is of no merit or validity.

Thread should have been locked, to be fair.

[Roboklopp]

http://espnfc.com/news/story/_/id/1705201?cc=5739

[Scratch]

Didn't big Andy elbow him earlier in the game though? From watching MOTD, i seem to remember there was an earlier incident that he should have been sent off for..?

They should have done that then. Accepted his appeal against the red card, then given him a red card retrospectively for the offence the referee missed. That way, everyone is happy!

[Bender]

The fact that Cheato Florres didn't get any kind of ban is what makes Carroll's red card even more harsh

[Gibbo]

Why would they ban him though? They obviously thought Carroll did enough to get sent off, and as it stands simulation is only a yellow card punishment.

[Exiled_red]

Was also convinced because Howard Webb was the ref, the FA would not want to overrule their supposed 'senior' ref.

The FA were never going to over-rule it there was contact so they can claim the decision was right, the only things they will over turn are cases of mistaken identity or if there was clearly no contact.

To over-rule a decision where there is contact i) risks undermining the referee and ii) would lead to loads more people appealing against decisions opening up a huge can of worms regarding severity of contact with is impossible to define clearly.

[ChesterDave]

They overturned the Spurs one despite the rear leg making contact long before the outstretched leg touched the ball

[Liverpool]

I dont think it was a red but didnt think it could be overturned easily either, hes took a little swing at his midrift and hes been bent low and hit him on the head. The intent was there but **** all in it

[Gibbo]

West Ham are appealing the appeal decision in court.

[Fivex]

Andy Carroll - West Hahahaham player

Yep, hoping this has some substance.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/26039222

Could get twitchy for the FA if they really do take things further but I think they'll wind their necks in pretty quickly.

[Catrin]

Yep, hoping this has some substance.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/26039222

Could get twitchy for the FA if they really do take things further but I think they'll wind their necks in pretty quickly.

They're worried that a three game ban for Andy Carroll could reduce their chances of staying up? Haven't they seen him play?

[Fivex]

He got 2 assists in that game didn't he?

Anyway I really want someone to challenge the FA on their inherently corrupt procedures. Just so long as it isn't us.

[Roboklopp]

Haha. Aye.

The irony of it being Fat Sam of the LMA Army makes it all the sweeter.