PFA Player of the Year 2011

[Chazza]

Shortlist:-

Charlie Adam
Scott Parker
Carlos Tevez
Gareth Bale
Samir Nasri
Nemanja Vidic

[Tee]

No Ryan Giggs?

[Alex]

Its got to be Parker? Has any other player carried a team as much? Plus done the duties of the manager with the half time team talks?

EDIT: FWIW I think the PFA are stupid for having this award with 2 months to go in the season.

[Fernandinho]

I can only take parker, only consistent performer all season?

[Chrono]

I'd go with Parker too but Bale has been outstanding and I have a feeling he will win it.

[Chrono]

God knows why Vidic is on there

[Chris]

Christ, what a horrific list. Shows just how bad this league is now.

Adam - He's had a good season and err thats it really.
Parker - Plenty of good but plenty of hopeless crap like on saturday where he was truly, truly horrendous.
Tevez - Excellent season.
Bale - Has he done anything since November?
Nasri - Similar to Bale. Started amazingly but dropped off.
Vidic - Still think this guy is a bit of a hype job, he's good but has to many games where he's just terrorised like on saturday.

[Shaggy]

For me Vidic has had a very good season on the whole, but yeah he is prone to throwing in far too many horror shows like Saturday.

Bit of a **** list isn't it.

Also surprised David Silva never made the cut, he's had a very good season. Class act he is.

[Bender]

no van der vaart either

[red g]

Modric has been better than Bale and VDV. Cannot believe he didn't make the top 6

[Shaggy]

Mancs going mad that Nani was ignored.

Kompany can consider himself unlucky too. Been a beast this year.

[Chazza]

Problem with this award is that it's voted for around January (I think?)

Players who have a good/great start to the season are always voted for, those who develop and improve as the season goes on will normally miss out

[Chazza]

Modric has been better than Bale and VDV. Cannot believe he didn't make the top 6

Been superb

[Tee]

If the votes were taken at the turn of the year, Nasri will have walked it.

[red g]

My premiership shortlist.

SWP
Scholes
Lennon
defoe
Malbranque
Tevez