PFA Player of the Year 2011

[Craig_H]

My premiership shortlist.

SWP
Scholes
Lennon
defoe
Malbranque
Tevez

Aside from Tevez, the others are surely a joke?

[red g]

Aside from Tevez, the others are surely a joke?

the answer was in my opening line

[red g]

although should have said spearring, but thought that was to obvious

[Craig_H]

the answer was in my opening line

What, 'my premiership shortlist' ? I dont get it

[Rudo]

No Steven Gerrard

[Assassin]

Shortlist:-

Charlie Adam
Scott Parker
Carlos Tevez
Gareth Bale
Samir Nasri
Nemanja Vidic

This has to be the worst shortlist ever

[red g]

What, 'my premiership 'short' list' ? I dont get it

[Shaggy]

Kelly ignored for young player.

PFA Young Player of the Year nominees: Bale, Coleman, Hart, Hernandez, Nani, Nasri, Wilshere.

[Gibbo]

The young player list looks to be stronger then the actual player of the year list!

[red g]

Kelly ignored for young player.

PFA Young Player of the Year nominees: Bale, Coleman, Hart, Hernandez, Nani, Nasri, Wilshere.

cant really argue with that list off the top of my head.
Not sure Kelly has played enough in the league to warrant an inclusion.

[Chris]

Seamus Coleman is rubbish, apart from be able to run quick anyway. Other than that its alright, though I still think having a 24 year old in the running for that award is utter stupidity.

[Shaggy]

Also Rafa van Der Vaart has been nominated for the main award, to go alongside the other six. Initial list was just a leak, this one is official.

[dww]

cant really argue with that list off the top of my head.
Not sure Kelly has played enough in the league to warrant an inclusion.

[Lee]

cant really argue with that list off the top of my head.
Not sure Kelly has played enough in the league to warrant an inclusion.

What has Coleman done this year to make that list?

Nasri, Nani and Hart are all 23 aren't they?! What's the cut-off? Think Kelly deserves a mention to be honest.

[red g]

What has Coleman done this year to make that list?

Nasri, Nani and Hart are all 23 aren't they?! What's the cut-off? Think Kelly deserves a mention to be honest.

the everton fans i know think he has done well this year, chipped in with half a dozen goals to and quite a few assists I imagine.

I dont know what the cut off point is.