Bellamy to Villa?

[LadyRed]

See what I did there?

Ha!

Yeah but if you were gonna find a poorer version of Cisse, it would be Martins.

[LadyRed]

Sorry I wasn't actually referring to Trez. I don't want him either. I was merely stating I want an out and out goalscorer (we haven't had one since Fowler/Owen), as opposed to someone who "contributes" to the team.

Oh sure, in which case I totally agree with you.

[Reece]

Ha!

Yeah but if you were gonna find a poorer version of Cisse, it would be Martins.

Nah sorry I have to disagree. I can certainly see the comparisons, I just think Martins will score more goals than Cisse.

[LadyRed]

Nah sorry I have to disagree. I can certainly see the comparisons, I just think Martins will score more goals than Cisse.

Maybe thats cos he actually starts up front as opposed to wide right. oh and the fact that he actually 'starts' too.

[simey85]

we need someone in the mould of james beattie!

[Reece]

we need someone in the mould of james beattie!

Mould being the correct word

[tomasjj]

Cisse is a better player than Martins.

Ouch....
Seriously?

[LadyRed]

Ouch....
Seriously?

Eh yeah, everyday of the week mate.

[tomasjj]

Eh yeah, everyday of the week mate.

Strongly disagree.
For me Cisse is devoid of footballing intelligence and thus not suited to play at this level.
Would Rafa have put him on the wing if he was a great striker?

I think Martins is much better, in terms of movement, general ability, footballing intelligence, link up play etc. He is also much stronger on the ball and agressive.

Cisse for me is a flashboy, fast, shots hard, makes unintelligent runs, gets caught offside, has a suspect attitude (all talk and no action), gets easily pushed off the ball...ok, I think I stop there.

Shame he is cack at Marseille. That means we won't get 8 mill for him...

[LadyRed]

Strongly disagree.
For me Cisse is devoid of footballing intelligence and thus not suited to play at this level.
Would Rafa have put him on the wing if he was a great striker?

I think Martins is much better, in terms of movement, general ability, footballing intelligence, link up play etc. He is also much stronger on the ball and agressive.

Cisse for me is a flashboy, fast, shots hard, makes unintelligent runs, gets caught offside, has a suspect attitude (all talk and no action), gets easily pushed off the ball...ok, I think I stop there.

Shame he is cack at Marseille. That means we won't get 8 mill for him...

Cisse has just come back from a broken leg!!! I can't believe how impatient people have been about his performances for Marseille.

Like I said Martins is a weaker version of Cisse, he's techically very poor with a poor reading of the game. Yes he's managed to score a few this season, but watch a few games of him, he's wasteful, poor decision-maker, and extemely undisciplined-he gets caught offside alot more then Cisse...and thats saying something.

The Fastest Crap Player in the World, as he was (not so) Fondly known as amongst the Inter fans.

[tomasjj]

Cisse has just come back from a broken leg!!! I can't believe how impatient people have been about his performances for Marseille.

Like I said Martins is a weaker version of Cisse, he's techically very poor with a poor reading of the game. Yes he's managed to score a few this season, but watch a few games of him, he's wasteful, poor decision-maker, and extemely undisciplined-he gets caught offside alot more then Cisse...and thats saying something.

The Fastest Crap Player in the World, as he was (not so) Fondly known as amongst the Inter fans.

Well, my observations are not only based on what he is doing now, but what he was doing when here at LFC.

Your analysis is completely off imo.

Do you have a soft spot for Cisse?

[DeeGame]

Well, my observations are not only based on what he is doing now, but what he was doing when here at LFC.

Your analysis is completely off imo.

Do you have a soft spot for Cisse?

[Lecter]

Well, my observations are not only based on what he is doing now, but what he was doing when here at LFC.

Your analysis is completely off imo.

Do you have a soft spot for Cisse?

I totally agree with your assessment

Cisse couldnt trap a bag of cement nevermind a football (and people moan about Kuyts first touch)

Cisse was imo the latest in a long line of expensive and rather useless forwards that Houllier signed

[LadyRed]

Well, my observations are not only based on what he is doing now, but what he was doing when here at LFC.

Your analysis is completely off imo.

Do you have a soft spot for Cisse?

Eh no.

I'm not a big Cisse fan, but I think alot of Lpool fans give him more stick than he deserves, and personally I would rather we has stuck with him than having Bellamy-but then thats cos I think Bellamy is a nasty piece of work-thats another stoty though.

My opinions of Martins are based on him at Inter too, I don't rate him at all.

Guess we'll have to agree to disagree.

[Lecter]

Eh no.

I'm not a big Cisse fan, but I think alot of Lpool fans give him more stick than he deserves, and personally I would rather we has stuck with him than having Bellamy-but then thats cos I think Bellamy is a nasty piece of work-thats another stoty though.

My opinions of Martins are based on him at Inter too, I don't rate him at all.

Guess we'll have to agree to disagree.

FLMAO you cant buy players just because they are nice people

Bellamy is twice the player Cisse was / is because he shows passion, commitment and effort on the pitch all three of which were totally alien concepts to Cisse