James Milner

[Liverpool]

been brilliant this calendar year, wide right and left back expert

[Rigadon]

Mr Reliable

[Rich]

Great player, simple as that.

[G]

Great player, simple as that.

The cry arsing when we signed him was ridiculous. "Bang average"

[dizzycat]

Immense game today, he also seemed to be a bit quicker...

[redmike65]

That's because he is closer (to ours hearts!).

[dom9]

The cry arsing when we signed him was ridiculous. "Bang average"

I always thought he was a bit overrated before he came to Liverpool. Reliable, functional, but not much beyond that. Now I think he's firmly rated.

[BobTheCharmer]

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo..........

I can't stand James Milner...... He is ****ing garbage.

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo................!!! !!

Sorry mate, could of been a number of people on page one of this thread going back to 2011!

[redmike65]

Yet to lose a league game in which he has scored, remarkable.

[G]

Sorry mate, could of been a number of people on page one of this thread going back to 2011!

Page 2 is more of an embarrassment than page 1!

[danperkins]

He was outstanding today

[Phoenix07]

Hamez Milner

[Gibbo]

He's playing well but I still dont massively rate him.

And honestly, if we didn't need a left back I dont think he'd be in the first team.

But, he is playing really well, cant fault that.

[Cormack74]

Page 2 is more of an embarrassment than page 1!

Looking back just now I'm actually surprised how many positive comments there were on that page - expected far worse.

[Rich]

Some frankly embarrassing **** in this thread.